News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why isn't there a replication crisis in math? by mjfl on Wednesday February 02, 2022 @03:34PM (#30183642)
because math doesn't do experiments.
Re:Why isn't there a replication crisis in math? by Jtsummers on Wednesday February 02, 2022 @03:56PM (#30183965)
Or as noted in the article:

> But one of the distinctive things about math is that our papers aren’t just records of experiments we did elsewhere. In experimental sciences, the experiment is the “real work” and the paper is just a description of it. But in math, the paper, itself, is the “real work”.

And

> And that means that you can replicate a math paper by reading it.

Re:Why isn't there a replication crisis in math? by horsawlarway on Wednesday February 02, 2022 @05:05PM (#30184732)
I think that means that the word "experiment" isn't the right term for what most mathematicians do.

I'd say most times it's "modeling", not "experimenting"

Re:Why isn't there a replication crisis in math? by NovemberWhiskey on Wednesday February 02, 2022 @03:51PM (#30183893)
This seems the obvious answer. The replication crisis isn't about published material being wrong, it's about the inability to reproduce the results of experiments or studies in a repeatable fashion.

It's not like you make a hypothesis in math and then need to go away and interview a sample of 1,000 circles and report back that, controlling for ellipses that may be misreporting as circles, the ratio of the circumference to the diameter is 3.2 +/- 0.1 (p<0.05).

Re:Why isn't there a replication crisis in math? by medstrom on Wednesday February 02, 2022 @03:56PM (#30183950)
Exactly. A math study is not a "study" in the sense of "hey i saw a funny pattern in some data maybe it's a sign of my pet theory" - it's literally already proven when published. There's nothing more to do.
Re:Why isn't there a replication crisis in math? by morelisp on Thursday February 03, 2022 @03:03AM (#30189906)
There are a lot of math papers / work that are "hey I saw a funny equation/morphism/shape/etc, what does it 'do'?" that present a lot of conjectures / constructions but are weak on any conventionally called a theorem. https://erich-friedman.github.io/packing/ is probably one of the best known on HN.
Re:Why isn't there a replication crisis in math? by nimih on Wednesday February 02, 2022 @04:01PM (#30184012)
https://www.experimentalmath.info/ would beg to differ, I think.
Re:Why isn't there a replication crisis in math? by bunje on Wednesday February 02, 2022 @04:39PM (#30184428)
"Mathematics is the part of physics where experiments are cheap." - V.I. Arnold
Re:Why isn't there a replication crisis in math? by pixl97 on Wednesday February 02, 2022 @09:43PM (#30187819)
Until you start multiplying infinities on your auto scaling AWS cluster
Re:Why isn't there a replication crisis in math? by horsawlarway on Wednesday February 02, 2022 @04:59PM (#30184659)
This is my take.

Science attempts to describe reality. Math attempts to create rules/axioms.

They're not the same pursuit, although they can often be useful together.

Re:Why isn't there a replication crisis in math? by Koshkin on Thursday February 03, 2022 @10:44AM (#30193860)
It does (especially using computers), it's just that experiment is not the sole criterion of truth as it is in, say, physics.