News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Senate introduces bill to allow farmers to fix their own ... by nyxtom on Wednesday February 02, 2022 @12:06PM (#30180368)
I wish these things were re-worded the other way. It's a sad state of affairs that a law has to be encoded to grant the people permission to do something that should be the default state. Right to repair is about targeting the manufacturers and preventing them from making it impossible to do so.
Re:Senate introduces bill to allow farmers to fix their own ... by ivan_gammel on Wednesday February 02, 2022 @01:53PM (#30182140)
It is not like that. People are allowed to do things, but they voluntarily cede the right to do them by agreeing to the terms of the contract, when they buy the hardware and services. So the role of the regulation will be actually to forbid certain types of contracts, that limit the right for repair, not to grant this right.

Also, the right to repair may mean different things: it can forbid exclusive contracts with spare parts suppliers, so that you could shop or repair elsewhere. Or it can regulate the price and availability. Or it can allow you to manufacture replacement parts on your own. The first option would be an equivalent of antitrust regulation in the vendor-specific ecosystem, and it seems pretty reasonable, because it will create a market where it did not yet exist. The second option will be economically destructive, because it would replace free market with planned economy. The last option may result in creating a black market of pirated parts, actually harming manufacturers which invested in R&D.

Re:Senate introduces bill to allow farmers to fix their own ... by jjoonathan on Wednesday February 02, 2022 @03:22PM (#30183463)
> voluntarily cede

That's the thing about contracts and debt -- they let people who have the advantage today rob you for not just what's in your pocket today, but what will be in your pocket tomorrow.

Re:Senate introduces bill to allow farmers to fix their own ... by SilasX on Wednesday February 02, 2022 @02:03PM (#30182286)
>So the role of the regulation will be actually to forbid certain types of contracts, that limit the right for repair, not to grant this right.

And to void previous contracts written that way.

Re:Senate introduces bill to allow farmers to fix their own ... by nyxtom on Wednesday February 02, 2022 @02:46PM (#30182982)
> So the role of the regulation will be actually to forbid certain types of contracts, that limit the right for repair, not to grant this right.

That's actually what I think the title should of been. But that's my own opinion.

"Senate introduces bill to forbid farming contracts that limit right to repair"

I get that, it's just a titling thing. Even framing the discussion in that way is not only a more accurate description of what's happening (as you've elaborated) but it lands better (if you were looking at this as a libertarian type perspective).

Anyway, it's just a thing that irks me is all.

Re:Senate introduces bill to allow farmers to fix their own ... by TheCoelacanth on Wednesday February 02, 2022 @06:20PM (#30185657)
Contracts would be meaningless without government enforcement, so an even more accurate framing would be "Senate introduces bill to stop helping tractor companies prevent farmers from repairing their tractors".
Re:Senate introduces bill to allow farmers to fix their own ... by ivan_gammel on Wednesday February 02, 2022 @04:34PM (#30184375)
Let's see what shape it will get when it's passed. As the article says, "The legislation would require agriculture equipment manufacturers to make spare parts, instruction manuals and software codes publicly available". This can go both in option 1 and option 2 direction.
Re:Senate introduces bill to allow farmers to fix their own ... by bpodgursky on Wednesday February 02, 2022 @12:48PM (#30181096)
Well, you can frame this both ways, because the contract clause, allowing people to (by default) sign binding contracts, also counts towards "grant the people permission to do something". And that's what this is — the farmer signing a contract to use the equipment in a certain way.

As much as this law makes sense, the blanket right to form contracts between individuals/businesses/etc (when those contracts are not explicitly deemed abusive) is very important and I don't think we would be in a better place without it.

Re:Senate introduces bill to allow farmers to fix their own ... by hyperhopper on Wednesday February 02, 2022 @01:14PM (#30181523)
On paper that all sounds well and good, but that completely discounts the power imbalance between large corporations and normal people.

When somebody wants to buy a good, if the only way to do that is to accept a one-sided ToS that makes them give up there rights, that's just eroding freedom.

The problem is, it's not a choice anymore. John Deere isn't saying "hey, want to sign up for our repair program?"

It's saying "If you want a tractor we actually control what you can do with it forever. Too bad you need this tractor to work, tough luck we own you"

Re:Senate introduces bill to allow farmers to fix their own ... by bpodgursky on Wednesday February 02, 2022 @01:19PM (#30181593)
That's why I am arguing that this law is good, but the default contract clause (which the OP comment is arguing against) is also good.
Re:Senate introduces bill to allow farmers to fix their own ... by salawat on Wednesday February 02, 2022 @01:51PM (#30182108)
This is actuslly the part where other tractor companies should be stepping in and eating Deere's lunch.

Why aren't they?

Re:Senate introduces bill to allow farmers to fix their own ... by vkou on Wednesday February 02, 2022 @03:35PM (#30183660)
Because they would rather have a 20% profit margin on 5% of the market, than a 1% profit margin on 50% of it?

Being in the latter position is precarious, being in the former is printing free money.

Re:Senate introduces bill to allow farmers to fix their own ... by salawat on Wednesday February 02, 2022 @04:06PM (#30184069)
Maybe if you spend your entire day looking at percents, and never get back down to dollars.

That 1% on 50% of the market can be a downright gold mine. Playing it the other way just ensures that bad ideas never get out competed. Honestly, it just takes less work to make something non user hostile. There has to be a perverse incentive somewhere.

Re:Senate introduces bill to allow farmers to fix their own ... by vkou on Wednesday February 02, 2022 @05:41PM (#30185146)
> That 1% on 50% of the market can be a downright gold mine.

Or a quick death spiral into bankruptcy in response to any disruption in business as usual.

This is a manufacturer of heavy industrial machinery, not a software startup, or a grocery store. You can't just turn down your burn rate by 1% in response to a 1% drop in demand, and you don't have a magical firehose of VC money that will smooth over any rough edges in your quest to improve the world by conquering the industrial machinery market, and driving all potential profits to near-zero with zero vendor lock-in.

Hell, the VCs will run away screaming when you get the 'zero vendor lock-in' part of your pitch.

Re:Senate introduces bill to allow farmers to fix their own ... by salawat on Wednesday February 02, 2022 @06:42PM (#30185986)
>and driving all potential profits to near-zero with zero vendor lock-in.

>Hell, the VCs will run away screaming when you get the 'zero vendor lock-in' part of your pitch.

Well there's your problem, right there. Stop looking at yourself as a financial frigging instrument. You make effing machinery. Not hold people logistically hostage. This is why there is no trust in industry anymore. This is why the same bloody handful of people are sitting on top of everything. This is why people have about had it. Can't solve a damn problem without making half a dozen more. Make tractors. All standard parts. High quality.

But no... Can't do that. Gotta try to exploit the rubes. This is why everyone feels like the damn game is fixed. The same power hungry assholes are the ones all sitting on the damn capital.

Anyone wants to try to compete? Lock em out of capital access! Start organizing? Lobby!

Re:Senate introduces bill to allow farmers to fix their own ... by gatlin on Thursday February 03, 2022 @08:17AM (#30192006)
Because no market has ever been free in any meaningful sense.
Re:Senate introduces bill to allow farmers to fix their own ... by JaimeThompson on Wednesday February 02, 2022 @12:51PM (#30181143)
Unlimited contracting rights, which I am not saying you support, are a very dangerous path to go down because history shows they will be abused in very serious ways to reduce the actual freedom of large subsets of the population.
Re:Senate introduces bill to allow farmers to fix their own ... by ivan_gammel on Wednesday February 02, 2022 @02:09PM (#30182387)
You are absolutely right that we should pursue more freedom in signing the contracts and this is exactly what such regulation is supposed to do: a contract with the vendor must not block signing the contracts with other suppliers and repair shops. It creates more freedom by being more explicit about what is a valid contract.
Re:Senate introduces bill to allow farmers to fix their own ... by gorjusborg on Wednesday February 02, 2022 @12:14PM (#30180502)
Exactly.

People should be able to repair their belongings. We shouldn't need a law for each type of belonging.

Re:Senate introduces bill to allow farmers to fix their own ... by queuebert on Wednesday February 02, 2022 @12:49PM (#30181107)
Apple glances around nervously.
Re:Senate introduces bill to allow farmers to fix their own ... by serverlessmom on Wednesday February 02, 2022 @01:16PM (#30181549)
Yeah I really thought it was clear how much of a huge bummer this news is. Rewrite is as 'Farmers are having their work held hostage by, of all things, tractor DRM, and there's a mere proposal to pump the breaks on this absolute cyberpunk nightmare"
Re:Senate introduces bill to allow farmers to fix their own ... by throwaway0a5e on Wednesday February 02, 2022 @12:16PM (#30180533)
I wouldn't read into it too much. This is just NBC's bias creeping in. It's not like they have a plethora of hardline libertarians kicking around who are gonna say "hey, can we title this differently?". The bill itself probably has some grand patriotic title.

Edit: Boring title and "text not available yet"

https://www.govtrack.us/congress/bills/117/s3549

Re:Senate introduces bill to allow farmers to fix their own ... by twobitshifter on Wednesday February 02, 2022 @01:55PM (#30182187)
That’s exactly my reaction, what about cars and phones and ordinary people? Politicians care are farmers, babies, and little old ladies because it gets people going, but the bigger issue is right to repair in general. It’s great that farmers would be able to fix tractors, but if the senate carves out this exception it could weaken the overall right to repair argument. Are there any broader bills being considered by the senate?