News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why the coverage of the trucker protest should worry all ... by nkurz on Tuesday February 01, 2022 @11:43PM (#30173807)
I found the intro a little confusing, but I think his conclusion is really strong and apt:

I am not writing this piece to advocate for the protest and its participants. I am writing this piece to ask Canadians like me whether we want our future protests to be judged and covered by standards applied to the truckers today. I am asking us to think about what happens to the horizon of possibility for mass organizing when we throw in with the idea that actual, authentic grassroots protests are a thing of the past and the only legitimate public demonstration is one choreographed from above, its participants carefully disciplined into reading from an identical script or into silence.

We should also think about the Proud Boys and Sons of Odin who have gone to the rally to radicalize its participants. The on-the-ground experience of regular folks participating will be of being called Nazis, traitors, Klansmen, bigots, etc. Not only will this place greater distance between the participants and urban Canadian society; it will make them look less unfavourably on others who are called Nazis and Klansmen. How bad could those guys really be, they will ask themselves? Were they also smeared as part of a bum rap by shills for the pharmaceutical industry?

They will wonder if those folks also came to be known as these things the way they did. As a person who, because I dissented from the progressive consensus on a single issue, has been smeared as a transphobe, homophobe, pedophile, white supremacist, racist and ableist in the past year and a half, I can no longer simply accept the opinion of centre-left media on whether someone is a dangerous, bigoted member of the alt-right. I can no longer trust the government-financed Canadian Anti-Hate Network on whether someone is a dangerous hatemonger because many of my comrades and I are on their list. And not everyone is going to be like me and check those claims against the facts. Most people will just start ignoring those claims.

There is a high price to pay when you decide to cry “wolf” over fascism in a political situation like our own, where the authoritarian threat is real and society-wide.

Re:Why the coverage of the trucker protest should worry all ... by jevoten on Wednesday February 02, 2022 @03:19AM (#30175078)
> I am writing this piece to ask Canadians like me whether we want our future protests to be judged and covered by standards applied to the truckers today [..] actual, authentic grassroots protests are a thing of the past and the only legitimate public demonstration is one choreographed from above, its participants carefully disciplined into reading from an identical script or into silence.

Obviously this is completely wrong - the author thinks there is any kind of principled consistency in how movements are covered. Protests have always been covered selectively by the media. If journalists or media conglomerates support the cause, they prominently feature the most sympathetic parts of the protests, and downplay others. If not, they do the opposite.

Had the author's views not been so in line with the establishment, he would have noticed this decades ago.

Re:Why the coverage of the trucker protest should worry all ... by DiggyJohnson on Wednesday February 02, 2022 @11:55AM (#30180185)
That is not "obviously completely wrong" for a number of reasons. One example of how there are novel aspects to this situation is a reversal of the politics of traditional establishment versus protestors. In the recent past, protestors were usually associated with liberal progressives, and the establishment upheld conservative (usually still within the realm of "liberal", though) principles.

Now we see the liberal-progressive establishment enforcing and narrating policies that concern conservatives (and many liberals - just my opinion). Additionally, the rhetoric used by the establishment is especially concerning, because the vitriol is coming from the highest levels without much effort to obfuscate.

Re:Why the coverage of the trucker protest should worry all ... by pc2g4d on Wednesday February 02, 2022 @09:07AM (#30177671)
Perhaps that is true. Or perhaps having an ideal of objectivity can increase objectivity, and abandoning such an ideal dooms us to exactly what you are describing.
Re:Why the coverage of the trucker protest should worry all ... by yunohn on Wednesday February 02, 2022 @08:32AM (#30177215)
Kinda odd why this comment is so downvoted, I was under the impression this was pretty common knowledge…
Re:Why the coverage of the trucker protest should worry all ... by AniseAbyss on Wednesday February 02, 2022 @10:30AM (#30178931)
"Grassroots"

LMAO we are not even pretending anymore that Canada is a sovereign state. Regardless of one's views on the Canadian government COVID policy it is not okay for a bunch of foreigners to come in and disrupt society with violent protests.

Is Canada now another chess-piece in the great American culture war? Always have been.

Re:Why the coverage of the trucker protest should worry all ... by 908B64B197 on Wednesday February 02, 2022 @06:35PM (#30185887)
> LMAO we are not even pretending anymore that Canada is a sovereign state

It echoes what a Canadian working in America told me: "you get the privilege of paying 30% more and earning 30% less, and you get to vote for someone who’s not there when the real decisions happen in Washington".

Re:Why the coverage of the trucker protest should worry all ... by DiggyJohnson on Wednesday February 02, 2022 @11:56AM (#30180202)
What are you referring to? Are you suggesting most of the protestors/truckers aren't Canadians?
Re:Why the coverage of the trucker protest should worry all ... by 8jef on Wednesday February 02, 2022 @11:32PM (#30188710)
Of course they are Canadians. Only their narrative is imported.
Re:Why the coverage of the trucker protest should worry all ... by pjc50 on Wednesday February 02, 2022 @04:32AM (#30175487)
So I went and looked up the radicalising incident: https://thetyee.ca/News/2020/09/23/BC-Ecosocialist-Leader-St... ; and without re-litigating the whole JKR controversy, he states as facts some things in that quoted post which are completely contrary to the reality of the treatment of trans minors, which is itself an extremely difficult treatment to access. It's not something pushed on anyone.

This is the "cancelled-to-alt-right-pipeline". Someone says a bunch of incorrect things that are harmful to a minority, is rudely corrected on social media, and decides to go hard to the other side.

Re:Why the coverage of the trucker protest should worry all ... by s1artibartfast on Wednesday February 02, 2022 @06:50AM (#30176344)
Thanks for sharing this context. It is ironic that the topic of Stuart's post was a call to stop canceling potential allies and pushing them to the alt right.

>he states as facts some things in that quoted post which are completely contrary to the reality of the treatment of trans minors

Coming at this with fresh eyes, He doesn't state anything as facts. He just summed up what JKRs position was and said this person is a potential trans ally.

As a result, he lost his political position and was canceled for begging people to think twice about canceling someone else.

Re:Why the coverage of the trucker protest should worry all ... by pjc50 on Wednesday February 02, 2022 @07:54AM (#30176825)
> He just summed up what JKRs position was

.. which was based on a set of wrong (and inflammatory!) claims about how trans healthcare works.

> and said this person is a potential trans ally.

Only in the sense that any alive person is a potential trans ally; you are not an ally simply because you claim to be, you have to actually do the work, and in JKR's case that means she would have to do a lot of work simply to undo the damage and hurt that she herself has caused to trans people.

You can't say "I would be an ally to those people if only they'd stop cancelling me!", that indicates a fundamental failure to understand what an ally is.

Re:Why the coverage of the trucker protest should worry all ... by s1artibartfast on Wednesday February 02, 2022 @10:28AM (#30178908)
It seems like he said, JRK is opposed to these 3 things.

If the trans community is also opposed to those 3 things, why wouldn't or couldn't they be an ally? There should be violent agreement!

Further, if the community wants 100 things, and someone supports 97, and disagrees on 3, must they be an enemy?

The point does indeed revolve around different definitions of what an ally is. Is it someone willing to work with you to get what you want, or get some of what you want, or is it someone who holds identical views?

The topic has strong parallels to the title post. Can the green party march alongside radical communists to protest climate change?

Re:Why the coverage of the trucker protest should worry all ... by Pigalowda on Wednesday February 02, 2022 @07:58AM (#30176864)
In the linked article there’s a Parker quote that doesn’t appear to be a list of facts - it looks like a summary of JKR’s position.

If he was booted for that then I believe he was just a casualty of a purity spiral.

Re:Why the coverage of the trucker protest should worry all ... by s1artibartfast on Wednesday February 02, 2022 @10:36AM (#30179028)
The federal Green party also expelled candidate Meryam Haddad from the party’s leadership race after for stating support for the BC Ecosocialists over the provincial Greens based on their climate policy, and then reinstated Haddad after she appealed the decision, and a provide a through condemnation of Parker.
Re:Why the coverage of the trucker protest should worry all ... by BeefWellington on Wednesday February 02, 2022 @10:00AM (#30178444)
> I am not writing this piece to advocate for the protest and its participants. I am writing this piece to ask Canadians like me whether we want our future protests to be judged and covered by standards applied to the truckers today. I am asking us to think about what happens to the horizon of possibility for mass organizing when we throw in with the idea that actual, authentic grassroots protests are a thing of the past and the only legitimate public demonstration is one choreographed from above, its participants carefully disciplined into reading from an identical script or into silence.

The main objection I have to this is that yes, I think I do want any protest whose organizers' demands are essentially "we'll take over for elected MPs and collectively this new government issue edicts to provinces" reported on in this way.[1]

> We should also think about the Proud Boys and Sons of Odin who have gone to the rally to radicalize its participants. The on-the-ground experience of regular folks participating will be of being called Nazis, traitors, Klansmen, bigots, etc. Not only will this place greater distance between the participants and urban Canadian society; it will make them look less unfavourably on others who are called Nazis and Klansmen. How bad could those guys really be, they will ask themselves? Were they also smeared as part of a bum rap by shills for the pharmaceutical industry?

This is a weak argument for a few reasons.

1. The "regular folks" here are decidedly in the tiny minority. "Regular folks" by the percentages in Canada got vaccinated and aren't harassing people who live near government buildings / borders. Ottawa and its immediate areas across the river in Quebec house about 1.5 million people collectively, and they were able to drum up about 20k at the peak, who all disappeared on Sunday.

2. While I think it's certainly possible some people out there somewhere have thought to themselves "well I guess I am racist, even though I think I'm not, and I guess it can't be all that bad", I've yet to see anything close to that actually happening. What I have seen happen is people who weren't vocal about *beliefs they already held* are now emboldened to share it, be it because they perceive the "others" to be responsible for their poor economic status or just because it's ingrained from upbringing.

3. The notes about the Proud Boys and the Sons of Odin joining the protest are interesting, because it's the same "not all protestors" thing that happens at ANY large protest. Is the suggestion that it's only the Sons of Odin and Proud Boys members laying on air horns for hours on end in the middle of the night?

4. This sets the bar as "unless it's an all out riot you can never judge a protest by the actions of its members." I don't agree at all.

There've been countless left- and right-side protests in Ottawa, and none that I know of have been like this. Consider: There has been a large March for Life protest pretty much every year since I left the city, and they do not turn violent or damage property: https://ottawa.ctvnews.ca/thousands-attend-march-for-life-do...

The reason it's getting the coverage it is is because it is deserved based on the actions of people associated with this particular cause.

The concept that the coverage there is only showing the worst behaviours is hilarious to me because of course it is. That's what the news media do. It isn't a left/right divide at all, it's a "what generates attention" divide.

[1]: https://canada-unity.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/01/Combined...

Re:Why the coverage of the trucker protest should worry all ... by oceanplexian on Thursday February 03, 2022 @03:47AM (#30190190)
> The "regular folks" here are decidedly in the tiny minority. "Regular folks" by the percentages in Canada got vaccinated

I won't speak to the other arguments you made but conflating "People who are vaccinated" with "People who agree with COVID restrictions" is frustrating and misleading.

For some reason the media keeps failing to make this distinction, e.g. "The protestors are a fringe minority, and that is because 90% of the population is vaccinated". You can look at the statistics of how many people are boosted (41% of Canadians) to see that not everyone is onboard with current public health recommendations, even if they were OK with the idea of getting vaccinated initially. If you start to deconstruct the numbers and look at polling there are a lot of indicators that the majority is not in favor of restrictions.

Re:Why the coverage of the trucker protest should worry all ... by BeefWellington on Thursday February 03, 2022 @09:44AM (#30193022)
Firstly, the full quote is actually:

> The "regular folks" here are decidedly in the tiny minority. "Regular folks" by the percentages in Canada got vaccinated and aren't harassing people who live near government buildings / borders.

That second part is significant and matters.

Secondly, in response to this:

> I won't speak to the other arguments you made but conflating "People who are vaccinated" with "People who agree with COVID restrictions" is frustrating and misleading.

As I noted above, I didn't do that. Let's discuss your example anyways. Canadians broadly support further restricting people who are not vaccinated.[1] Next, Canadians broadly support ending COVID restrictions and trying to return to normal.[2] In the same study ([2]) nearly half (49%) of those surveyed blame the unvaccinated for prolonging the pandemic.

It might be ugly but the general attitude these polls suggest is one of "if you're not working with us, you're working against us."

> For some reason the media keeps failing to make this distinction, e.g. "The protestors are a fringe minority, and that is because 90% of the population is vaccinated". You can look at the statistics of how many people are boosted (41% of Canadians) to see that not everyone is onboard with current public health recommendations, even if they were OK with the idea of getting vaccinated initially. If you start to deconstruct the numbers and look at polling there are a lot of indicators that the majority is not in favor of restrictions.

I addressed the latter part above. However, that 41% number is disingenuous for a few reasons.

1. The booster campaigns only began for the general population in December. In a number of provinces there is a minimum wait time for getting a booster shot after your second shot.

2. Each province handles health care on its own, so responses are different and rules are different all across the country. You can see numbers at a few places but there's a tracker at CBC that's still being updated.[3] The globe also has an article about the uptake slowing and suggests it's there's a variety of different reasons than just individual attitudes (though that is undeniably a factor for each vaccination).[4] On that page they chart out doses administered. Because supply was much higher the spike is much larger for the booster than dose 1 and the trend appears in most provinces to be following the second shot. Consider: 41% of Canadians got the booster within two months of the start of booster campaigns. This suggests it's actually pretty popular.

[1]: https://globalnews.ca/news/8532791/covid-unvaccinated-restri...

[2]: https://angusreid.org/omicron-incidence-restrictions/

[3]: https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/track-how-many-people-have-be...

[4]: https://www.theglobeandmail.com/canada/article-uptake-of-cov...