Re:America’s Covid job-saving programme gave most of its cas...
by wyager on Tuesday February 01, 2022 @09:40PM
(#30172932)
The US isn't a corporation, it doesn't own my productive output, and random UBI recipients never paid for their shares.
If you set up a country with this idea from the start (a profit-seeking corporation with transferable shares), it might be a good idea, but probably no net beneficiaries of UBI would have shareholder status.
Re:America’s Covid job-saving programme gave most of its cas...
by tastyfreeze on Wednesday February 02, 2022 @12:32AM
(#30174109)
That analogy only works if we get UBI paid by profit of weapons sales, not taxes. Otherwise UBI is like your employer keeping half your paycheck and distributing 30% of the money to everybody, whether they earned it or not, while keeping 20% to administer the redistribution.
Re:America’s Covid job-saving programme gave most of its cas...
by CMCDragonkai on Tuesday February 01, 2022 @08:43PM
(#30172416)
Wouldn't that mean UBI should divided a proportion of annual GDP?
Re:America’s Covid job-saving programme gave most of its cas...
by anonporridge on Tuesday February 01, 2022 @08:53PM
(#30172517)
Sure, pegging it to GDP sounds like not a bad idea.
As the nation gets more productive, everyone's effective UBI goes up.
If the real value of the UBI gets to be too high and too many people stop working in balance with automated labor, then GDP starts to decline and people start getting worse off and increasingly incentivized to find some productive work to do.
Seems like it could end up being a self balancing system.
Re:America’s Covid job-saving programme gave most of its cas...
by tacitusarc on Tuesday February 01, 2022 @09:25PM
(#30172788)
In fact instead of lending Fed inflation dollars to big banks, we could partially fund a UBI with those same dollars!
Re:America’s Covid job-saving programme gave most of its cas...
by alistairSH on Tuesday February 01, 2022 @08:36PM
(#30172366)
Which is pretty much Alaska.
Think of it as a dividend on your citizenship.
Every person a shareholder of the nation.