News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:German gov plans software company's liability for damages... by tasubotadas on Tuesday February 01, 2022 @02:42PM (#30168047)
Users. They shouldn't use software that they haven't wetted as secure.

No amount of regulation will save users from installing a hundred of toolbars if they want to do that.

But it will hinder legitimate programmers from publishing useful software (especially free and open source software).

Re:German gov plans software company's liability for damages... by cdirkx on Tuesday February 01, 2022 @03:10PM (#30168492)
How is this different from saying "We shouldn't cross bridges that we haven't vetted as structurally sound."? I don't expect everyone to have an architectural degree, as well as the time and resources to verify everything without access to the building plans.
Re:German gov plans software company's liability for damages... by einherjae on Tuesday February 01, 2022 @03:00PM (#30168336)
That only makes sense for FOSS, where part of the deal is that the software is provided for free, but with no guarantees about fitness for purpose.

Would you except restaurant-goers to be liable if they get poisoned? Now compare that to picking your own mushrooms, or dumpster diving. Part of the deal when you start charging for something, has to be that the customer can expect the product to… work.

Re:German gov plans software company's liability for damages... by josephg on Tuesday February 01, 2022 @08:04PM (#30172152)
Huh? How??

How are users supposed to vet all the software we run? How are you supposed to know that a compiled binary from Wacom snoops on your computer? That gmail - or, worse, some random startup has no security vulnerabilities?

Users don’t have time to read the source code for every product. Even if they did, we don’t have the source code for most software on our devices. And even if we could get that, we don’t have access to any of the code running on someone’s web server.

Saying users are responsible is the same as saying nobody is responsible.

The only way a user can take responsibility is to refuse to use products and services from startups & young companies who don’t have a reputation yet. And if people feel the need to start doing that, it’s bad for everyone.