I've concluded mandates are useless because they got weaponized- the harder you try to push for vaccines, the harder the people who associated with antivax will push.
I'm curious what outcomes would have been different if we'd reached, say, 99.99% vax in the US.
Gibraltar: - vaccination: two doses >99%, boosted: 85% - cases: 145 (7 day avg)
Gibraltar population is 33k. This is pretty good example that vaccines can't stop the spread. With examples from other highly vaccinated countries (e.g. Portugal, Australia), it doesn't look it's a path to end covid.
You should get vaccinated to improve your own chances, but taking it to protect others doesn't really work.
> the harder the people who associated with antivax will push.
Does your definition of antivax include people who are vaccinated but oppose mandates? Because I would fit that definition and don't consider myself antivax since I do recommend vaccination to people who didn't get it yet. With small difference that I don't want to force them.
And one last question for those who propose mandates. When will mandates end? What happens after 6 months when you're no longer considered vaccinated? Do you subscribe to mandatory vaccination indefinitely?
I'm not sure what the detailed semantics of "is pro-vax but anti-mandate an anti-vax" position. There's a distinct difference from "anybody should be able to get the vax to protect themselves" and "we should impose mandates because vaccines are most effective when 95+% of the population takes them." If the latter were an extremely strong scientific position (IE, if there was a guarantee of herd immunity at 95% rate) then I think it would be a slam dunk.
I believe the mandates would be done when their effectivity is over. It's not like the people who want to impose these things are doing it because they enjoy exerting power over people. Anyway, there weren't any real large scale mandates forcing people to get vaccinated, so it's kind of moot?
There are 119 new positive cases in Gibraltar today. 71 are vaccinated and 48 are unvaccinated.
If vaccines didn't prevent transmission, one would expect that second number to be 10 or less given the base rate of vaccination.
All I sad that vaccines can't stop the spread and it still looks like that. I didn't say they don't reduce it or that they're not beneficial otherwise.
Personal anecdote time: I got covid from person who was fully vaccinated 2 months before and didn't have any symptoms. Btw. since this was second time for me, plus with vaccines in the mean time, it was like a very mild cold, one day of temperature and some coughing afterwards.
Hm, numbers I'm googling for Gibraltar don't really add up - population 2021: 35.120, fully vaccinated: 40.722. One explanation would be that there are non-rezidents who are working there and got vaxed, while not counted as population.
Re: your other point, no vaccine is 100% effective at "stopping" spread. Absolutely no vaccine is 100% effective. There is no qualitative difference between prevention and reduction. If it reduces spread, then by definition some nonzero number of potential infections were prevented.
Ok, next bigger countries on vacc list:
- UAE: population 9.3m, 94% fully, 2400 cases 7-day avg
- Portugal: population 10.3m, 89% fully, 55k cases 7-day avg
Especially Portugal's cases don't support that 90% vacc stops spread in any meaningful way.
In this way, a reader can deduce what they believe is the closest truth available rather than it be shouted down at them. The fact that grujicd did not interpret Gibraltar data accurately is, I believe in this case, not a mark against them but a testament to how well they formulated their argument that flaws can be evaluated easily.
public health authorities on the other hand will begrudgingly hand over data after months of outcry, as well as change testing criteria and engage in many other methods of purposeful/accidental obfuscation, making their arguments hard to decipher.
I can't really help you if your opinion is that public health authorities are working in bad faith.
You're free to present different numbers, but please don't cite anything pre-Omicron since it's not relevant any more.
Once more, my case is that current vaccines are not a way to stop spread and therefore vaccinating low-risk population like kids won't protect the elders. I fully support vaccination for self benefits. As I did for myself.
It looks like the mainstream health authorities have shared up to date information on the protection against infection by omicron by vaccines. If that's the case, doesn't it mean that vaccinating kids would protect elders?
It seems like one can argue for the former without arguing for the latter, but in the current crisis both sides of this debate are conflating the two.
The study it points to shows that vaccination reduces spread by 40%. It’s a small study with n’s of <40 people, but 40% is a significant reduction in transmission.
Beyond that it tries to somehow ignore the massive benefits in reducing the risk of hospitalization (therefore ignores the fact that even when the vaccinated spread the virus, they are likely to in lower intensity), by claiming that a bad flu year has 50-70k hospitalized Americans. Which is true, and just goes to show how much worse the impact of COVID is on hospitalization when the hospitalization winter peaks have been 140k and 160k, more than double the worst flu season in the US. And no, 12% of the staff not being available (largely because they are burnt out because of COVID) is not even a part of the reason that hospitalization is so much of a problem when hospitalization is 100% greater than the worst flu year.
2) The article does not provide strong studies showing the benefits of reinfections. Other than a letter to the editor, the data ends pre-Omicron, but more importantly, covers a period which is well within the 6-9 month period of the last 2 surges where immunity from both vaccines and infection is considered strong. There is research showing that immunity due to infection does, in fact, reduce dramatically after 6-9 months. It may take some time for the effects of Omicron to be isolated, but either way, at best it shows that variants are able to evade immunity by infection.
3) Finally, they don’t actually provide any downsides to the vaccine mandates. And there are no novel civil liberty based defenses one can hide behind because vaccine mandates already exist for many vaccines. At least in the US, courts have ruled in favor of mandatory vaccinations even over religious objections.
Arguably the likes of Jenny McCarthy, who have been anti vaxxers well before COVID-19 existed can take a principled stance against vaccine mandates, but it’s very difficult for others to do so considering they’ve been accepting them for so long with nary a word against them.
Consequently, an argument against a strong vaccine mandate must test on a cost benefit analysis, and it’s hard to argue against the mandate on a cost benefit analysis, and I don’t see how pointing out a bunch of benefits, without showing any costs (to those who don’t have medical exemptions, who presumably would be exempt from any version of a vaccine mandate) leads to a conclusion against mandates.