News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Federation Fallacy (2019) by pessimizer on Tuesday February 01, 2022 @09:20AM (#30162713)
Ideally I prefer a consent model, where each user has a list of other users they approve of, and a list of users whose lists they approve of (which may be identical.) That's what social networks were sold as. Servers should be dumb providers that are primarily worried about bandwidth.

Sure, it cuts down on serendipity, but if you want that, you can subscribe to serendipity345's feed which will add anybody who asks, and will autodelete based on the proportion of bans issued from list subscribers (or a selected council) on a particular user, card-check[0] style..

Federation at the server level is a poor substitute for the lack of finer grained governance tools.

Democracy and auctions are a last resort when you can't find a real solution. They ensure a type of fairness, but have awful failure modes. The ideal situation is when people are only exposed to what they want to be exposed to. The dangers of filter bubbles are 1) who controls them, 2) how they distort the information used for decisionmaking, and 3) who controls them. Absolute, dynamic control of your own filter bubble might make you stupider, but you should have the right to be stupid if you want to be.

-----

[0] Under card-check, when the majority of people in your shop sign a union card, you're a union shop, no need for an election.

Re:The Federation Fallacy (2019) by daniel-cussen on Tuesday February 01, 2022 @10:24AM (#30163711)
> Absolute, dynamic control of your own filter bubble might make you stupider, but you should have the right to be stupid if you want to be.

Individual users are entitled to filter out things they don't want to hear. They own their computer, they're paying for the electricity and network, everything takes place on their hardware, which is their property, presumably confined within their actual home which is also their property. The computer presents itself as a window to the world, but despite literally being billed this way by eg. Microsoft Windows, it is closer to a tapestry placed on a wall.