News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Socrates on the blessing of being refuted by goodpoint on Monday January 31, 2022 @03:38PM (#30153947)
> what is a morally unacceptable debate?

I'm surprised that people here do not understand this point. Here some by-the-book examples that are used in ethics 101:

"what is the best way to kill grandma?" "what is a reasonable price to buy a slave?"

If you find murder or slavery immoral you are simply unable to debate on this questions because they imply acceptance of the premise.

You can, of course, express your disagreement on the whole debate.

> I see no winning outcome in making it a taboo

This has nothing to do with a taboo. It's a completely different thing.

Re:Socrates on the blessing of being refuted by NikolaNovak on Tuesday February 01, 2022 @09:24AM (#30162766)
I've taken Philosophy 101 and Ethics 101 (admittedly not much further), and I've never found an inkling that discussion/debate itself is immoral; I don't even know how you'd consider an idea, to label it as moral or immoral, without, you know, considering and debating it (internally or externally).

I can debate the best way to kill grandma; I will even find it intellectually stimulating; heck, I just spent a few minutes now that you brought it up pondering that (it's the whole "don't think of pink Elephant" schtick:); without in any way implying acceptance of the premise, condoning the action, or considering actually doing it. Does your brain work different? Can you disentangle a concept and idea from action and emotion? I don't feel you're making your point persuasively, or the choice of phrasing may be ambiguous.