Re:Former nuclear leaders: Say ‘no’ to new reactors
by pseudalopex on Saturday January 29, 2022 @06:53PM
(#30131919)
Published death rates include models of excess mortality. Those models include accidents. Output is relevant because demand is constrained by price and applications. Not deaths from available technologies.
Re:Former nuclear leaders: Say ‘no’ to new reactors
by arcticbull on Saturday January 29, 2022 @08:46PM
(#30132916)
Further the nuclear excess mortality is in my opinion likely to be overstated, as - correct me if I'm wrong - they are primarily computed using the LNT (linear, no-threshold) dose-response model. This model is quite controversial and at best represents a worst-case. [1]
I have never understood the rationale behind that measure. First of all, radiation only directly causes death in most extreme circumstances - but even before it will increase the likelihood of severe diseases like cancer or will cause birth defects in the next generation. Deaths/TWh captures none of that stuff.
Second, why is the energy output even in there? We know nuclear is a high-yield energy source. That doesn't tell me anything about the likelihood of accidents over time or my personal risk while living next to a power station (or next to a disposal site).
By the same logic, you could conclude that binge-drinking alcohol is safer than drinking water as it's deaths/hours of fun measure is lower.
Or that chucking Earth into the sun would actually be an even safer method of producing energy than nuclear: Sure that would cause some 8 billion deaths, but look at that energy output!