See this presentation "Manufacturing of Silicon Materials for Microelectronics and Solar PV" for an overview of how industry turns quartzite and coal (dirty) into ultra-pure silicon:
https://www.osti.gov/servlets/purl/1497235
If I were to guess, I would say that India's largest obstacle to domestic silicon production and refining is the price of electricity. The processes need a lot of electricity so they tend to be located in areas where it is available at low cost.
Huh? Your cleanroom standard for semiconductor manufacturing is more stringent than air quality in Switzerland. I think general air quality matter less when you can use sophisticated cleanroom equipments.
As per my observations, even most of the graduates don't continue in the field, they either go to foreign countries for graduate studies, and almost never come back - or switch careers to IT/Consulting/Finance through an MBA within a decade of graduation.
You got desserts, water scarcity, earthquakes, security risks - pick two.
I know the fact Silicon does not come from Sand but mostly from Quartz. That is not speculation.
I do not know the effects of dust in air with respect to how that will have effects on Fab.
Fabs are water intensive -- that I know and growing up Indian states always used to have water tensions
As disclaimed -- I do not know it fully but I am not completely clueless as you suggest.
1. Every major design corp has India campus, so India definitely has the talent for design
2. Coming to Fabs -- India lags big time. Why?
I am going to give a half-informed answers -- please fact check and correct me.
a. Dust -- at least the lower peninsula is Dusty (this has to do with Monsoons & Western ghats ..)
b. Water -- It is very hard to find the kind of intensive water facilities that do not go against agriculture sector
c. Silicon -- comes from Quartz and Indian Quartz comes from Andhra and Telangana is not of great quality
I can see India having fabs for domestic consumption and lower end.. not for export or bleeding edge.
note: Please down-vote if you think that is right and also provide feedback where I am wrong -- that would actually help here.