News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[dead]
Re:Wire is now on F-Droid by kmeisthax on Friday January 28, 2022 @02:02PM (#30118912)
>The censorship Gab has faced from those in the Fediverse directly conflicts with the Four Essential Freedoms of Free Software which people in this community supposedly uphold. Most notably, censoring Gab goes against the first of these freedoms – “the freedom to run the program as you wish, for any purpose.”

No, this is not a Freedom Zero violation. Refusing to distribute software is not equivalent to banning you from running that software as you wish - unless there's some vrmsPhone out there that only runs signed F-Droid packages. Refusing to peer with a particular Mastodon node is also not violating Freedom Zero - I mean, "do not connect to Gab" is a valid way to use the software and plenty of people do not want to talk with people who use Gab. Are we seriously saying that having a blocklist in an app is a Freedom Zero violation now?

Furthermore, not wanting to talk with someone is not, in and of itself, censorship. If this were Google or Facebook, then maybe you could argue that they have monopoly power, or that we should have some kind of common carrier regulation on them. But those are, at best, special cases justified by the outsize market power of FAANG companies. The argument being put forth by Reclaim The Net is that freedom of speech isn't about being able to speak to willing ears, but about forcing people to listen to you.

Re:Wire is now on F-Droid by commoner on Friday January 28, 2022 @02:10PM (#30118999)
Yes, the argument is wrong. Freedom 0 allows User A to run their own instance of the F-Droid server as they wish. It does not allow User A to compel User B to run User B's instance of the F-Droid server the way User A would like it to be run. If the argument were true, any user would be able to control another user's instance of a free software network application, which would be a serious violation of property rights.

If User C's instance of the F-Droid server hosts a repository with Gab in it, and User D connects that repository to their F-Droid client, the client would be able to download and install Gab. This shows Freedom 0 in action.

Re:Wire is now on F-Droid by cyborgx7 on Friday January 28, 2022 @01:50PM (#30118766)
The idea that people who dedicate a significant portion of their lives to developing and maintaining free software projects would be politically neutral is so funny to me. And yet it keeps being an assumption that is made on here.
Re:Wire is now on F-Droid by hartator on Friday January 28, 2022 @01:59PM (#30118874)
Well for some alternative app store named f-droid, you expect them to be the home of all the rejections of the Play Store. What the point of jailbreaking your phone if you end up with the same limitations.
Re:Wire is now on F-Droid by commoner on Friday January 28, 2022 @02:01PM (#30118901)
F-Droid specializes in free and open source software. It does not specialize in software rejected from other app stores. F-Droid is also available on all Android phones, rooted or not. Android allows apps to be sideloaded if no app store meets the user's needs.
Re:Wire is now on F-Droid by cyborgx7 on Friday January 28, 2022 @06:00PM (#30121681)
>Well for some alternative app store named f-droid, you expect them to be the home of all the rejections of the Play Store.

That is a strong misunderstanding on your end, then. F-Droid is a free software client to a repository of free software apps, for people who prefer free software and maybe even contributing to the possibility of running free software only on your android phone.

It has nothing to do with being a home of rejected apps from the Play Store.

Re:Wire is now on F-Droid by joomooru on Friday January 28, 2022 @01:56PM (#30118838)
Funny thing is with these "free speech" advocates, allowing hate speech (antisemitism, racism, sexism, etc.) on your platform is anything but politically neutral. It's obviously capitulating to hateful groups like white supremacists/neonazis.
Re:Wire is now on F-Droid by vorpalhex on Friday January 28, 2022 @02:03PM (#30118922)
You can always not read/watch/support people you dislike.

Censors are biased like everyone else. There are always extra casualties.

Re:Wire is now on F-Droid by joomooru on Friday January 28, 2022 @02:05PM (#30118948)
Tell that to the victims of the Pittsburgh synagogue shooting victims: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gab_(social_network)#2018_Pitt...
Re:Wire is now on F-Droid by vorpalhex on Friday January 28, 2022 @02:27PM (#30119185)
Well good thing no bad person has ever posted on Facebook.. or Twitter.. or Instagram.. or written a manifesto and sent it via USPS.

Facebook has literally been used to livestream rape and murder!

And your own source says Gab turned everything over to the FBI. What, exactly, is the fault here? Them not having a time machine?

Re:Wire is now on F-Droid by heavyset_go on Friday January 28, 2022 @07:43PM (#30122515)
Gab can always run their own F-Droid repository, as well.
Re:Wire is now on F-Droid by francis-io on Friday January 28, 2022 @02:00PM (#30118891)
Of course it's politically neutral. Inaction is neutral.
Re:Wire is now on F-Droid by joomooru on Friday January 28, 2022 @02:08PM (#30118979)
Sorry, political neutrality doesn't exist.

Inaction in the face of injustice, means you are advocating for the status quo. E.g. the white moderate from Letter from Birmingham Jail.

Re:Wire is now on F-Droid by young_unixer on Friday January 28, 2022 @02:40PM (#30119362)
Then radical left speech shouldn't be allowed either, but many Mastodon instances allow communists (like, they literally call themselves communist) without any issue.
Re:Wire is now on F-Droid by monocasa on Friday January 28, 2022 @02:46PM (#30119428)
Once again, the goal isn't to be politically neutral.
Re:Wire is now on F-Droid by gruez on Friday January 28, 2022 @02:25PM (#30119173)
Why is that strange? Up until a decades ago, the ACLU fought for both communists[1] and nazis[2]. If you're fighting for software freedom (ie. the narrative of freeing people from the oppression of google/apple app stores), it makes sense for your position to be "software freedom for everyone", not "software freedom for everyone, except nazis because fuck them".

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/American_Civil_Liberties_Union...

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/American_Civil_Liberties_Union...

Re:Wire is now on F-Droid by lucgommans on Friday January 28, 2022 @01:51PM (#30118782)
I did not mean to make this a political discussion when I submitted this news.

If there are other open source app stores that Wire is on, feel free to add those in a comment and/or a submission. Coming here just to hate on f-droid for a past decision does not seem productive to me.

Re:Wire is now on F-Droid by hartator on Friday January 28, 2022 @01:43PM (#30118679)
Fun that the first opportunity they had to make a difference they choose censorship over openness.
Re:Wire is now on F-Droid by npteljes on Friday January 28, 2022 @01:53PM (#30118812)
They are making the difference by providing their excellent service.
Re:Wire is now on F-Droid by npteljes on Friday January 28, 2022 @01:52PM (#30118795)
Are they claiming that they're neutral, or have they violated any such promise, code of conduct, ethical statement or anything? If not, then I'd consider this a moot point.
Re:Wire is now on F-Droid by devwastaken on Friday January 28, 2022 @02:07PM (#30118963)
So what? Political neutrality doesn't exist. We all make political decisions every day. Gabs owners and staff intentionally make money off of lies, slander, and in general being dishonest slimeballs. We as individuals actually do have a responsibility to the truth and to prevent political scammers like gab from profiteering off of lies.
Re:Wire is now on F-Droid by px43 on Friday January 28, 2022 @02:22PM (#30119133)
Opposition to Gab has nothing to do with politics. It is very specifically a platform for spreading hate speech and fostering collaboration for hate groups. Believing that black people, Jewish people, Muslims, women, LGBT, etc are inferior subhumans who don't deserve rights is not a legitimate "political viewpoint".

While it is absolutely true that hate groups have been doing their darndest to infect Republicans and conservative Americans with their hatred, that does not legitimize their hatred, and it should never, ever be tolerated in a civilized society.

Re:Wire is now on F-Droid by gruez on Friday January 28, 2022 @02:34PM (#30119290)
>Opposition to Gab has nothing to do with politics

>[...] is not a legitimate "political viewpoint".

Can you apply this on the other side as well? eg. "believing that people don't deserve property rights (ie. communism) is not a legitimate 'political viewpoint'".

Re:Wire is now on F-Droid by px43 on Monday January 31, 2022 @02:27PM (#30152922)
Your use of the term "other side" make no sense in this context. Hateful individuals exist across all nationalities, ethnicities, and party lines. These are people who believe that certain types of other people aren't actually people, and they don't deserve rights. Giving them a voice and a platform always leads to violence. If we want to live in a peaceful multicultural society, the only option is to deplatform hateful individuals whenever they emerge.

They absolutely should not be legally forbidden from speaking/publishing. There is no conflict with our first amendment rights. They need to be appropriately labeled, and platforms that promote them should be publicly shamed. Gab allowed, encouraged, and protected some of the most vile white supremacists on the internet. It is absolutely within F-Droid's rights (and IMO their moral obligation) to deny their app.

Re:Wire is now on F-Droid by vecplane on Friday January 28, 2022 @01:43PM (#30118681)
Why exactly did they ban Gab?
Re:Wire is now on F-Droid by dleslie on Friday January 28, 2022 @01:45PM (#30118708)
Here's their statement[0], and this is the meat of it:

> F-Droid as a project soon celebrates its 9th birthday. In these 9 years, F-Droid’s mission was and is to create a place where people could download software they can trust – meaning only free, libre and open source software is available on its flagship repository. As a project, it tried to stay neutral all the time. But sometimes, staying neutral isn’t an option but instead will lead to the uprise of previously mentioned oppression and harassment against marginalized groups. We don’t want and won’t support that. F-Droid is taking a political stance here.

> F-Droid won’t tolerate oppression or harassment against marginalized groups. Because of this, it won’t package nor distribute apps that promote any of these things. This includes that it won’t distribute an app that promotes the usage of previously mentioned website, by either its branding, its pre-filled instance domain or any other direct promotion. This also means F-Droid won’t allow oppression or harassment to happen at its communication channels, including its forum. In the past week, we failed to fulfill this goal on the forum, and we want to apologize for that.

0: https://f-droid.org/en/2019/07/16/statement.html

Re:Wire is now on F-Droid by scarby2 on Friday January 28, 2022 @01:55PM (#30118828)
Basically - it became a go to for the Alt-Right, these guys ruin everything.

Sad thing about free speech on the internet is that while i'm largely in favour of it mostly it does create breeding grounds for openly hostile and harmful opinions/people.

Given the lack of education in most of the world this is sadly utterly terrifying and i have no idea what to do about it.

Re:Wire is now on F-Droid by dleslie on Friday January 28, 2022 @02:25PM (#30119170)
> this is sadly utterly terrifying and i have no idea what to do about it.

IMHO, accounts need to have non-trivial value, to all users. Social pressure will do much of the rest.

The problem with Gab, Twitter, Facebook, Reddit, even HN and such is that accounts are free and do not meaningfully increase in value with time and activity. This allows bad actors to thwart social pressure by simply switching accounts at their leisure.

It also doesn't help that there _usually_ exists few barriers to access to online communities; people tend to have a romantic view of being open and welcoming, and social networks have an incentive to keep access generally open as it increases user retention.

Re:Wire is now on F-Droid by chc on Friday January 28, 2022 @01:47PM (#30118736)
Their stated rationale is that Gab serves disproportionately as a place to organize activities that reduce people's freedom, such as harassment campaigns against minority groups and anti-democratic activity like voter intimidation, and so they felt that hosting it was less in the spirit of freedom than banning it.

Ultimately, it's a problem that all pro-freedom platforms have to deal with: How much freedom should you give people to take away other people's freedom? When one group of people wants another to be less free, any action you take will result in a loss of freedom for someone.

Re:Wire is now on F-Droid by hellcow on Friday January 28, 2022 @01:59PM (#30118878)
> How much freedom should you give people to take away other people's freedom?

This is the very purpose of law according to John Locke who heavily influenced America's founders. To John Locke, the way to maximize freedom for everyone was by establishing laws which restrict people's ability to remove others' freedoms.

Having platforms like F-Droid self-govern and establish rules to try and maximize freedoms in the world is a pretty interesting experiment and a great showcase of small government, and thus should be widely supported by conservatives :)

Re:Wire is now on F-Droid by scarby2 on Friday January 28, 2022 @05:51PM (#30121577)
> Having platforms like F-Droid self-govern and establish rules to try and maximize freedoms in the world is a pretty interesting experiment and a great showcase of small government, and thus should be widely supported by conservatives :)

Most modern day "conservatives" are not in fact conservatives. They dont seek a return to or a preservation of any traditional value at this point and instead seek radical change into a new and uncertain future. They have largely abandoned conservatism and replaced it with something entirely more terrifying.

Re:Wire is now on F-Droid by deadalus on Friday January 28, 2022 @01:45PM (#30118700)
F-Droid banned Gab for being a “free speech zone” that will “tolerate all opinions”.[0] Now Gab has been banned from Google Play Store, Apple App Store as well as from F-droid due to negative media pressure.

[0]https://f-droid.org/en/2019/07/16/statement.html

Re:Wire is now on F-Droid by semilattice on Saturday January 29, 2022 @10:47AM (#30127215)
Gab supports legal speech, uncensored.

Speech control (Censorship) is used to remove 'independent thinking' as a state of mind.

The current view in US, Russia, UK, China, Canada, etc and most of other countries -- is that 'leadership', 'business leaders', and 'the scientists' -- know better.

Independent thinkers usually, not simultaneously fluent in economics, biology, geopolitics, financial services, etc. So when they question not just 'status quo' promoted by the 'leadership', but also the motives behind that -- they are labeled various bad names (eg. uneducated, backwards, etc..)

Gab exists for independents to share, develop, often change the position that one builds up questioning the authorities.

The authorities, of course, consider that a threat. And so does F-Droid.

F-Droid, therefore is not for freedom. It is for complacency.

I am Jewish, was an atheist just a year ago, now studying Torah, Talmud, etc. My background is mathematics (abstract algebra) and CS. Not observant (yet) – as I writing this on Shabbat.

My family escaped dictatorship before, and now I am seeing it is being built up here -- different words, of course, but same action as was done by Mao, Stalin, Hitler (label, suppress, exterminate (or suffocate economically as in case in UK/US/Canada) )

I visit gab quite often (well ... a couple of times a week, for me that's often).

Most of the posts, just like on HN -- I do not find intellectually stimulating. A lot of repetition, etc -- but for me, they key is to know that people have freedom of communication and expression. It is more important than if I agree with what they express.

I am also glad that Gab now have some politicians, and people who are running (in US politics) on there as well.

Doctors (with anti mRNA-mandate stance), like Robert Malone is there as well.

I also think that this un-reasonable boom in bitcoin valuation made a number of people rich enough -- to not go through the typical ladder of VC/financial services, high-paying jobs route.

Which means that we now have a number of millionaires who want to project their influence, their position on free speech -- who did not grow up in the 'status-quo' world. This is also a positive outcome of BTC (even though I missed the boat on crypto!)

Re:Wire is now on F-Droid by vecplane on Saturday January 29, 2022 @10:59AM (#30127321)
Thanks for your reply. Which dictatorship did you escape?

I'm happy to hear that more people are finding value in religious texts.

Re:Wire is now on F-Droid by rvz on Friday January 28, 2022 @03:39PM (#30120053)
Telegram is a brilliant alternative and a free libre and open source software (FLOSS) which is used by tons of users.

However, like Gab, it has all the same “oppression and harassment”, or everything that F-Droid has quoted:

'Things like racism, sexism, verbal abuse, violent nationalist propaganda, discrimination against gender and sexual minorities, antisemitism and a lot more things become popular on such instances.'

Those same people that are on Gab are also on Telegram. So why have they not taken a 'political stance' against it or 'banned it' like they have banned Gab?

Re:Wire is now on F-Droid by svnpenn on Friday January 28, 2022 @01:48PM (#30118741)
Of course this comment, and all the children, leave out any context of the other side, so allow me to:

> Widely described as a haven for extremists including neo-Nazis, white supremacists, white nationalists, the alt-right, and QAnon conspiracy theorists

https://wikipedia.org/wiki/Gab_(social_network)

Re:Wire is now on F-Droid by hartator on Friday January 28, 2022 @01:55PM (#30118830)
This is unfair characterization. Because Gab sticks to a very liberal (in the traditional sense) interpretation of the 1st amendment, it's probably the home of marginalized voices. However doesn't mean Gab supports their points of view.
Re:Wire is now on F-Droid by monocasa on Friday January 28, 2022 @02:11PM (#30119009)
The CEO's public statements disagree with the assertion that they don't agree with and support extreme far right views.

For one example of many, here he is decrying the evils 'Judeo-Bolshivism', a literal Goebbels era Nazi propaganda concept from the 1930s that somehow the Jews invented communism as a part of their master plan to control the world.

https://www.dailydot.com/debug/andrew-torba-deactivates-gab-...

So it doesn't seem like that unfair of a characterization to me.

Re:Wire is now on F-Droid by mdp2021 on Friday January 28, 2022 @05:10PM (#30121122)
How can you create an unmoderated forum and not have it populated by all sorts - especially those refused by moderated forums.

"Haven for all sorts" is the "destiny" of any unmoderated communication platform.

Re:Wire is now on F-Droid by eole666 on Friday January 28, 2022 @01:55PM (#30118827)
I bet if fdroid was censoring an app mainly used by antifa and persons from the radical left you'd be quite happy. But they rather sensor a social network used almost uniquely by alt-right / fake news writers / neonazi / hateful people, and now you're here complaining about it not being neutral.. Go create your own free right wing app store if you want Gab in it.
Re:Wire is now on F-Droid by young_unixer on Friday January 28, 2022 @02:44PM (#30119408)
I'm not parent comment, but I wouldn't be happy either if they started censoring antifa or any kind of speech.
Re:Wire is now on F-Droid by ospzfmbbzr on Wednesday February 02, 2022 @10:09AM (#30178572)
> if fdroid was censoring an app mainly used by antifa and persons from the radical left you'd be quite happy.

No. That violates free speech and I'm not intellectually dishonest.

> uniquely by alt-right / fake news writers / neonazi / hateful people

How do you know?

Nobody goes to a FREE (as in beer) app repository for politics.

The maintainers should resign if they have any sort of moral compass (I'm not holding my breath)

At least we can all finally agree on where authoritarian censorship comes from -- the radical left. Why is that? Can't win any arguments?