News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Obama Signs Patent ‘Reform’ Bill by tzs on Sunday September 18, 2011 @08:10PM (#3011669)
This bill contains a major blow to patent trolls. The new joinder rules make it much harder to sue multiple defendants in one suit. Companies like Lodsys that want to sue dozens of companies will have to do it in dozens of separate suits.

This hurts them in three ways:

1. Their litigation costs will go way up.

2. Defendants will be much more successful in getting venue changes to a forum of their choice, instead of being force to defend where the troll files. (When there were multiple defendants in one suit, carefully chosen by the troll to be from all over the country, it was hard for a defendant to get a venue change to their home turf because the court would want to keep all the cases together for judicial efficiency, and there would be no district that would be better for all the defendants). This further drives up the costs to the troll because now they will not only be litigating dozens of suits, they will be scatted are over the country.

3. They have a much greater chance of losing their patent. Each trial provides an opportunity for a judge or jury to decide on any number of grounds that the patent is invalid. Once a patent is ruled invalid, that's it for that patent.

There's a good post elaborating on those points from Red Hat's senior patent counsel here: http://opensource.com/law/11/9/new-patent-reform-law-could-r...

Toss in the new rules making it easier to challenge a patent, and the new rules that increase the scope of prior art, and this is overall a pretty good bill from a programmer's point of view.

Re:Obama Signs Patent ‘Reform’ Bill by marshray on Sunday September 18, 2011 @09:32PM (#3011832)
s/patent troll/small inventor/ and all your logic remains valid.

The only thing this significantly benefits is large companies' ability to kill off smaller competition.

Patents should be completely abolished as a relic from the age of steam. This is the 21st century.

Re:Obama Signs Patent ‘Reform’ Bill by teej on Sunday September 18, 2011 @09:52PM (#3011882)
Woah, wait a second. Small inventors are not filing suits against dozen of defendants in carefully chosen jurisdictions. Often, they'll just target the top few companies breaching the patent. They aren't looking to make a living on patent settlements, they're looking to make a living on the technology they invented.

Soheil Sharafabadi sues 3 Universities over mustard seed patent - http://seattletimes.nwsource.com/html/localnews/2009794832_a...

Jim de Cordova sues one company over sleep mask patent - http://news.yahoo.com/dreamcloud-sleep-mask-inventor-sues-sl...

A retired engineer sues Clorox over bleach patent - http://ww2.gazette.net/stories/082407/businew12306_32368.sht...

A Pennsylvania woman sues Victoria Secret over bra patent - http://www.docstoc.com/docs/75307539/Pennsylvania-Inventor-S...

There are dozens of stories like this. The profile of a small inventor case looks nothing like these patent troll cases.

Re:Obama Signs Patent ‘Reform’ Bill by alanX on Monday September 19, 2011 @12:00AM (#3012174)
there are... dozens?

Are you seriously defending the billions that the patent system costs our economic system with the idea that it protects "dozens" of individuals and small businesses?

Seriously, if you stack up the number of patent lawsuits and license fees extorted by IBM, TI, Microsoft, and others against small tech firms, the damage to small business by the patent system is overwhelmingly larger than the benefit some small businesses might gain from it.

Re:Obama Signs Patent ‘Reform’ Bill by jamesaguilar on Monday September 19, 2011 @12:25AM (#3012232)
His point is merely that the logic does not evenly apply to patent trolls and small inventors. He is saying nothing about the overall benefits of the patent system.
Re:Obama Signs Patent ‘Reform’ Bill by Helianthus on Monday September 19, 2011 @12:40AM (#3012280)
The point is not that the patent system is wholly sane, but that it is made somewhat more sane by a careful imposition of legal costs that by and large affect only patent trolls.
Re:Obama Signs Patent ‘Reform’ Bill by marshray on Monday September 19, 2011 @02:10AM (#3012517)
Small inventors are not filing suits against dozen of defendants in carefully chosen jurisdictions. Often, they'll just target the top few companies breaching the patent. They aren't looking to make a living on patent settlements, they're looking to make a living on the technology they invented.

Why not? Simply because small inventors have to pay retail price for their lawyers, whereas the patent trolls typically are (or have regular full time) lawyers. There's nothing inherent in the "small-inventor-ness" of the plaintiff that makes them file suit in certain patterns.

Therefore, a small inventor may get a better deal either selling the patent to the manufacturing company or making good on the threat to sell it to a trolling firm who will aggressively seek to ruin them. Better that than waste their life savings on legal expenses that will likely drag on for years.

Re:Obama Signs Patent ‘Reform’ Bill by AJ007 on Sunday September 18, 2011 @11:10PM (#3012058)
I'm very concerned no one in the tech press have pointed at that the biggest technology companies are in the stages forming a cartel. Small companies are now locked out of the handheld mobile device market unless they can raise and pay millions of dollars in licenses and fees. The future looks sad.
Re:Obama Signs Patent ‘Reform’ Bill by marshray on Monday September 19, 2011 @02:20AM (#3012545)
Well, yeah, that's the point of a patent.

Many people seem to be in disbelief about this but the purpose of a patent is to give the holder a monopoly on the "invention", at least in the sense that the patent can be used to prevent anyone else from doing anything productive with it.

Stupid, huh?

Re:Obama Signs Patent ‘Reform’ Bill by Poiesis on Sunday September 18, 2011 @10:08PM (#3011930)
I'm having trouble putting your two statements together into a coherent whole. You say that making life more difficult for patent trolls will make it harder for smaller shops,but then go on to advocate abolishing patents, which does not strike me as terribly friendly to the smaller inventor.
Re:Obama Signs Patent ‘Reform’ Bill by marshray on Monday September 19, 2011 @12:15PM (#3014106)
A. I advocate abolishing patents. Some type of temporary protection would need to be provided for the very rare exceptional case of the development of new drugs. I can think of very very few, if any, cases where 21st century patents have actually contributed to "progress in the useful arts". Instead, they are universally a drag on people who actually produce things of value.

B. People may point to an exception case here and there, but the proverbial small inventor with a patent is a thousand times more likely to have his life savings eaten up by lawyers than to actually get paid for a useful invention. I don't think an improved patent system is actually going to help the small inventor.

C. This particular law looks to me like it further enhances large companies' ability to kill off smaller competition.

I don't think that there is a contradiction here.

Re:Obama Signs Patent ‘Reform’ Bill by alanX on Monday September 19, 2011 @12:03AM (#3012183)
Anyone that wants to actually ship a product is aided by removing the fear of patent lawsuits.

If someone wants to sit around and think up ideas, and earn license money from those ideas, well then they need patents. Producing products is just different than thinking up ideas and filing broad patents and suing people that actually produce products.

Re:Obama Signs Patent ‘Reform’ Bill by gridspy on Sunday September 18, 2011 @10:24PM (#3011967)
Essentially - Creating products and selling them in an open marketplace is easier and fairer for the Entrepreneur than obtaining and defending patients is.