Re:Bridge collapse in Pittsburgh’s Frick Park
by omnicognate on Friday January 28, 2022 @10:47AM
(#30116092)
> Nobody is advocating for object permanence.
I am. People need to understand that bridges continue to exist when they're not looking at them.
Re:Bridge collapse in Pittsburgh’s Frick Park
by throw10920 on Friday January 28, 2022 @02:12PM
(#30119022)
100% reliability is physically impossible. "reliability" is defined to include resistance to abnormal situations. A bridge might be 100% reliable when winds don't exceed 100mph...an event that might have a 1% probability per year in its area of construction, which is clearly highly unlikely, but still something that is accounted for in reliability, uptime, and failure rate metrics.
I don't even know if you can achieve 100% reliability given a set of plausible situations/usage, because you'd have to imagine every single possible failure mode for the thing that you're building.
That is - the threat of "destruction" proper (which you contrasted with "collapse without prior warning") is included in the reliability metrics for a device.
The point stands. Nothing that humans build can be 100% reliable - the only thing you can do is asymptotically approach it.
Now, that said - three nines per year is way too low for me, personally. Five nines is more comfortable (and if it's cheap I'd like to go higher).
Re:Bridge collapse in Pittsburgh’s Frick Park
by opwieurposiu on Friday January 28, 2022 @11:18AM
(#30116619)
Did you watch this video? Tom claims in the video that the barrier is designed for up to a thousand year tide. That's essentially the same as the three nines standard I advocated.
People advocate for understood constraints of critical infrastructure. Engineers usually have knowledge about longevity and reliability of components.
There are examples of man-made systems which absolutely require 100% reliability, but those still have lifetimes and will be destroyed at some point to be replaced with something else[0].
A bridge can be destroyed, but it should not collapse without prior warning.
[0]: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eY-XHAoVEeU