News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ivermectin Prophylaxis Used for Covid-19 by tptacek on Friday January 28, 2022 @12:22AM (#30110946)
That's one of several critiques of the study; others includes the fact that it's not controlled for confounders, that the city in question had the highest COVID mortality in its state during the program, and that several of the study authors have either conflicts, bad reputations, or both. The Twitter link itself links to even more damning critiques, including some evidence of falsified data.
Re:Ivermectin Prophylaxis Used for Covid-19 by srcreigh on Friday January 28, 2022 @12:54AM (#30111095)
I read the city had high mortality from the beginning of the pandemic[0]. Would it be a bad case if the population happens to be more aged etc?

Is the falsified data just the off by one in deaths among the under 30 cohort or is there more?[1]

[0]: https://mobile.twitter.com/sean_purdy/status/147041652307654...

[1]: https://mobile.twitter.com/GidMK/status/1478975913094090752

Re:Ivermectin Prophylaxis Used for Covid-19 by snovv_crash on Friday January 28, 2022 @08:06AM (#30114075)
[0] could also be due to a high incidence of worms in the population.
Re:Ivermectin Prophylaxis Used for Covid-19 by naasking on Friday January 28, 2022 @08:24AM (#30114242)
> that the city in question had the highest COVID mortality in its state during the program

This is not a critique of the study really. The high mortality could be due to other factors, like an older population or less careful application of other COVID mitigations. If the latter, this study would actually be a good test case for prophylactic Ivermectin actually because the signal from any effect would be stronger.

Re:Ivermectin Prophylaxis Used for Covid-19 by torstenvl on Friday January 28, 2022 @06:58AM (#30113560)
> That's one of several critiques of the study; others include[] . . . that several of the study authors have either conflicts, bad reputations, or both.

That is not a valid critique of the study. It is a potentially valid reason to adjust your Bayesian priors applicable before reading the study, but is utterly nobprobative as to whether the science is sound.

Re:Ivermectin Prophylaxis Used for Covid-19 by FabHK on Friday January 28, 2022 @08:07AM (#30114086)
Agreed. When Pfizer studies the effectiveness of their vaccine, they also have conflicts. That doesn't impugn the results of the study, if it's well done.
Re:Ivermectin Prophylaxis Used for Covid-19 by avs733 on Friday January 28, 2022 @08:36AM (#30114374)
No, it is a critique.

When Pfizer does it it is a critique as well.

The question is how much of a critique.

In general…

If you are dishonest about your conflict, you hide it, don’t do anything to control for it then having a conflict is a bigger critique.

If you are transparent about your conflict, honest about what it is, and take measures to control for it or add extra steps to analysis to prevent potential bias - then a conflict is a less strong critique of the study.

Critique in scientific research isn’t a binary. It isn’t “there’s one critique and it’s valid or not and if it’s valid the study is bad”. There can be critiques of ANY study. No study is perfect. But the types and the details of the critiques matter collectively to make the study better or worse.

Collectively, this study falls to the worse end. It’s not just the conflict of interest it’s the conflict of interest + the study design. The critiques of the study design are that this study is design almost exactly the way you would if you wanted to increase the appearance of effectiveness of this treatment.