After reading Dune and also being an engineering leader, I’ve come to view power as multivariate. In some ways you have less power when you’re in charge. To go with your example, many other countries didn’t see a choice in getting involved in WW1.
Re:Who Got It Right: Orwell or Huxley?
by cjbgkagh on Thursday January 27, 2022 @05:52PM
(#30108167)
One of my takeaways from 1984 is that those who are supposedly in charge are slaves to a self perpetuating emergent behavior. It often feels like it is never a choice. How much of politics is decided by Henry Kissinger and his disciples (e.g. Klaus Schwab - Davos) carrying on the tradition of realpolitik.
Re:Who Got It Right: Orwell or Huxley?
by spaetzleesser on Thursday January 27, 2022 @05:57PM
(#30108229)
“those who are supposedly in charge are slaves to a self perpetuating emergent behavior”
That describes most of society and for sure a lot of companies. A lot of people realize that something is not right but they still stay confined within that framework.
Re:Who Got It Right: Orwell or Huxley?
by native_samples on Friday January 28, 2022 @05:16AM
(#30112815)
Big Brother wasn't self perpetuating though. The book is mostly about the enormous efforts and manipulations required to sustain it.
The emergent behavior in this example includes big brother and those who perpetuate it. Just because something is costly doesn’t mean it can’t ensure it’s continued existence.
“Self perpetuating emergent behavior” is the best summary I’ve ever heard of this phenomenon
Re:Who Got It Right: Orwell or Huxley?
by ashtonkem on Thursday January 27, 2022 @05:59PM
(#30108247)
Sending Lenin to Russia wasn’t about causing a revolution, that had actually already happened, but it was about trying to affect who would win the following fight for power.
Power is a hell of a drug.
Re:Who Got It Right: Orwell or Huxley?
by NikolaeVarius on Thursday January 27, 2022 @05:54PM
(#30108199)
> i.e. the Russian Revolution was an intentional act done to it by cynical Germans who correctly expected the outcome would help them in the war.
Claiming that Germany caused the Russian Revolution via the sole act of sending him back to Russia is not true.
While it is true that Lenin ultimately led the Bolsheviks to power, the reason Germany even thought about sending Lenin back was that Russia was already on the brink of collapse due to reasons a mile long and Germany was throwing shit against the wall to hasten Russian collapse.
Claiming a revolution of an entire country was caused by a single person is a bit much.
Re:Who Got It Right: Orwell or Huxley?
by cjbgkagh on Thursday January 27, 2022 @06:07PM
(#30108345)
No such claim, it was over 30 exiles, and I suspect were also given large amounts of money and weapons. It’s a murky area of history, I haven’t dug deep enough to be able to authenticate supposed forgeries etc. but prima facie it would make sense.
Possibly my favorite example of the powerful impressing a way of life on a huge number of people is the diplomatic sealed train the Germans used to send Lenin from Switzerland to Russia. i.e. the Russian Revolution was an intentional act done to it by cynical Germans who correctly expected the outcome would help them in the war. And the rest is history.