News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Who Got It Right: Orwell or Huxley? by mjfl on Thursday January 27, 2022 @05:21PM (#30107739)
Huxley seems to be more right in the long term, since Orwellian oppression is very visible, people work to fix it and eventually do. Not so for Huxly-an dystopia.
Re:Who Got It Right: Orwell or Huxley? by jabbany on Thursday January 27, 2022 @06:10PM (#30108376)
> Orwellian oppression is very visible

Yes.

> people work to fix it and eventually do.

No?

My understanding of Orwellian oppression is exactly that even though people are very aware that it exists, only a small minority of people care enough (or are personally harmed enough) to want to take actions change it.

Just look at modern day China. All but the most naive are aware of things like censorship and surveillance. Most have first-hand interactions with both. People joke about it all the time (being "invited for tea" or such and such news was "harmonized" a.k.a. censored). Some of the language has evolved to be almost not that different from what was envisioned in Newspeak.

And yet, the average person does not feel violated enough to actually do something about anything. It's much easier to just go with the flow and not do what the state doesn't like.

Re:Who Got It Right: Orwell or Huxley? by Clubber on Thursday January 27, 2022 @06:29PM (#30108570)
>And yet, the average person does not feel violated enough to actually do something about anything. It's much easier to just go with the flow and not do what the state doesn't like.

The problem is it requires a lot of people to make a difference. A single person or a small group protesting gets thrown into a reeducation camp for 20 years (if they are lucky). That's one of the reasons mass surveillance is so nefarious; you can't start to plan a mass assembly/protest to address grievances without being noticed beforehand and thrown into a reeducation camp for 20 years (if you are lucky). You can't even talk about grievances with more than a few other people in a dark closet somewhere.

Re:Who Got It Right: Orwell or Huxley? by jabbany on Thursday January 27, 2022 @06:31PM (#30108585)
Right, and that was the point of the Orwellian dystopia. Even if a single person sees the dystopia for what it is, they cannot get the masses to act.
Re:Who Got It Right: Orwell or Huxley? by Clubber on Sunday January 30, 2022 @04:08PM (#30141113)
It's even more insidious than that. Even if the masses see the dystopia for what it is, they can't come together to fight it, because surveillance will be watching their coordination efforts.

In North Korea I suspect most everyone knows the propaganda is bullshit, but even a whisper of dissent will send the police knocking at your door. We aren't as bad as North Korea of course, but it sure smells similar.

Re:Who Got It Right: Orwell or Huxley? by time_to_smile on Thursday January 27, 2022 @05:33PM (#30107902)
The trouble is I'm perfectly fine with the Huxlian distopia. Ship me off to an island of intellectual dissidents and give me some good drugs, I'm down for that world.

Kafka is the one who really got it right. I've never felt a more realistic depiction of my life than The Trial.

Re:Who Got It Right: Orwell or Huxley? by cjbgkagh on Thursday January 27, 2022 @05:43PM (#30108049)
I'd be down for 60 years of good health, I think of the amount of work that I could do. I think the problem is that they have to keep throwing the work away and the pointlessness of it all would kill me.
Re:Who Got It Right: Orwell or Huxley? by mrjangles on Thursday January 27, 2022 @07:11PM (#30108958)
There is a related thread on the problems Argentina is currently facing. It is worth reading through to see just how wrong you are. The problems Argentina is facing are well known and obvious and no one is doing anything about it, those problems have existed for decades. The newspeak is so strong in Argentina that even in that thread no one will say the real reasons out loud.

Even when I was there 20 years ago, people had to hush whisper and look around to see who was listening when talking about the problems they were facing.

Re:Who Got It Right: Orwell or Huxley? by bhelkey on Thursday January 27, 2022 @07:22PM (#30109050)
> The newspeak is so strong in Argentina that even in that thread no one will say the real reasons out loud.

What's stopping you from saying what you think are the real reasons?

Re:Who Got It Right: Orwell or Huxley? by mrjangles on Friday January 28, 2022 @07:50PM (#30122578)
Don't want to bother getting into a fight strangers on the internet. The reasons are obvious and well know. Just look at any country in South America that is suffering and it is always the same reason - socialism.
Re:Who Got It Right: Orwell or Huxley? by WillPostForFood on Thursday January 27, 2022 @05:39PM (#30107984)
Orwellian oppression is very visible, people work to fix it and eventually do.

At least in 1984, oppression wins. It is a very bleak ending.

Re:Who Got It Right: Orwell or Huxley? by mehlmao on Thursday January 27, 2022 @06:33PM (#30108601)
It wins over Winston, but not forever. The appendix on Newspeak is written in past tense, implying that at some time it came to an end.
Re:Who Got It Right: Orwell or Huxley? by colecut on Thursday January 27, 2022 @05:23PM (#30107764)
Nearly everyone carries an internet connected camera microphone tracking device everywhere.
Re:Who Got It Right: Orwell or Huxley? by Hnaomyiph on Thursday January 27, 2022 @05:27PM (#30107831)
Does a camera, microphone and tracking device detect a slowly boiled frog?
Re:Who Got It Right: Orwell or Huxley? by NikolaeVarius on Thursday January 27, 2022 @05:57PM (#30108236)
> Orwellian oppression is very visible

1984 makes a fairly strong point that this is not true.

The proles do not conceive of the fact that they are oppressed. Only the outer party can even think this, and at best its a muted response. Newspeak is about making it impossible to see or conceptualize oppression or injustice.

Re:Who Got It Right: Orwell or Huxley? by native_samples on Friday January 28, 2022 @05:15AM (#30112803)
Ironically, the article and this discussion seems like a good case in point!

"Totalitarianism was Orwell's Nineteen Eighty-Four, in which the state controlled everyone through the infliction of pain and terror"

That sounds far closer to our current existence than BNW. Where are my bread and circuses? Circuses were shut down for much of the last two years, because of the need to fight an ever-shifting war against a terrifying virus ... a danger that cannot be directly perceived because almost everyone who gets it has mild symptoms and recover after a few days, but which rather, can only be truly perceived through the telescreen in our living rooms and the pronouncements of the ruling classes.

The parallels to 1984 are everywhere recent times, yet the majority cannot see them. Newspeak is in abundance. Policies change overnight and yet the Party claims that the policy was always the same, previously famous people get erased instantly the moment they object, and the population is trained to demand their own oppression, believing ultra-harsh conditions to be an expression of love.

Re:Who Got It Right: Orwell or Huxley? by jancsika on Thursday January 27, 2022 @06:05PM (#30108326)
> Newspeak is about making it impossible to see or conceptualize oppression or injustice.

But were the proles forced to use Newspeak? I thought they were singing folks songs and stuff...

Re:Who Got It Right: Orwell or Huxley? by robocat on Saturday January 29, 2022 @06:51PM (#30131897)
Newspeak was primarily for the political classes, with the aim of absolute political control: ultimate authoritarianism of a system of thought (also see Sapir–Whorf hypothesis). By controlling language, all dissenting political opinions could be prevented, with the eventual goal that any thought that wasn’t the official line (such as liberty) could have only the single word ‘crimethink’ to describe it. Big brother and Emmanuel Goldstein (the revolutionary against the state) were fictions of the system, permanent idealised placeholders for the system. The system rules: people within the political system are trained by the system to be perfect cogs with zero independent thought, and the higher up in the hierarchy the less control and more mechanically thought-constricted the person became. Over time the system restricted thought, restricted language, and as the political class were replaced over the decades, the upcoming people were evermore controlled by the system. The only goal of the system was complete and total control.

The proles made up the majority of the population, but are almost invisible in the book, which leads to some odd Internet comments. The proles have zero political thought, and they live short lives of poverty. The proles are programmed to be interested in meaningless songs (produced by the versificator machine), meaningless persuits (such as lotteries), and other diversions. The proles do not speak newspeak, because they are not political. They certainly didn’t sing traditional folk songs (English aka ‘oldspeak’ is slowly abridged, removing all political words and nuances, and old literature is destroyed by rewriting it to remove all political nuance).

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Newspeak

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thoughtcrime

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Linguistic_relativity

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Big_Brother_(Nineteen_Eighty-F...

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Emmanuel_Goldstein

Re:Who Got It Right: Orwell or Huxley? by NikolaeVarius on Thursday January 27, 2022 @06:16PM (#30108444)
I dont think the proles were, since they were already in a state where they could not recognize they were under the Party's boot.

"The proles are free"

Newspeak was supposed to stamp out "bad" thoughts from members the party.

Re:Who Got It Right: Orwell or Huxley? by 62951413 on Thursday January 27, 2022 @06:29PM (#30108556)
How about Huxley is for 1st world rich countries like the US and Orwell for poor ones like the Soviet/Putin's Russia?