News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Bada Bing, Bada Boom: Culture inside Bing by bambax on Sunday September 18, 2011 @08:20AM (#3010080)
Search engine internals are really not my point here (I build Lucene-based search engines for a living).

My point is about user experience and user expectations.

I expect a search engine to find documents that contain the words I'm searching for, not other words it thinks are equivalent, or some other document that has a better "ranking". Ranking is sorting the pages that actually contain words in the query, not in abstracto. Ranking is about relevance, not popularity; popularity is but one piece of information when calculating relevance.

> The missing terms are falling out of the front page due to low rank

In the example I gave, a word is replaced by another word, not just ignored; one can tell because the replaced word is highlighted in the search results, as if it was the one I was looking for.

> Focus group doesn't decide how algorithmic search works

Focus groups can help decide if a feature is or isn't worth it. Some user feedback is useful; relying too much on user feedback and losing sight of the original mission of the company is dangerous. (Remember "Organize the world's information" and all that?)

- - -

It's likely there are solid and sane reasons why Google is doing this (and of course they're free to do as they want -- since we don't pay for their services who are we to complain); what I don't get is why these "features" cannot be turned off (as can Instant).

There are no comments on this comment yet.