News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Pfizer board member suggests end to mask, vaccine mandates by srcreigh on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @01:05PM (#30089192)
Encouraging natural immunity is asking for hospitals to get filled up by people giving themselves covid on purpose. This affects non covid patients too.

I suspect that's why the media doesn't do it.

Re:Pfizer board member suggests end to mask, vaccine mandates by ifyoubuildit on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @01:58PM (#30090073)
This response is actually an example of what I'm talking about.

The comment that I replied to was explaining how the segment of the population that is a candidate for giving themselves covid while being high risk is (and has been) shrinking out of existence.

Meanwhile, there is a much larger (and growing) cohort that continues to be harrased if they (fairly) decide they don't need these vaccines, and the harrasment is justified by claims like yours.

Even the CDC has finally come around and published data along these lines (despite numerous studies suggesting the same starting from early last year). But after bullshitting people for so long, I guess we just have to expect there will be a ton of inertia behind the idea that every human needs these vaccines, no matter what.

Re:Pfizer board member suggests end to mask, vaccine mandates by srcreigh on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @02:07PM (#30090208)
Why doesn't someone make the point that 95%+ (or 98%+ etc) of Americans are protected via natural immunity or vaccines and back it up with data?

Once that point is made, the discouraging natural immunity argument can stop because hospitals can't overfill anymore.

However until that point can be made[0] I think the "don't encourage natural immunity" position will prevent the most deaths.

By the way, I also don't condone harassment of unvaccinated people or vaccination as a requirement for employment etc either. Those are separate issues to me.

[0]: I tried looking for it but CDC data is only sept 2021 and estimated only 146M infections https://www.cdc.gov/coronavirus/2019-ncov/cases-updates/burd...

Re:Pfizer board member suggests end to mask, vaccine mandates by ifyoubuildit on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @02:28PM (#30090469)
I attempted to make an argument like that 2 weeks ago.

I was using an estimate of 120m instead of the 146 that you quoted. And I'm just a dummy on the internet, so I'm probably at least a little wrong. But the gist was that if you could jab everyone tomorrow (which you can't), you might get a little bit of a benefit in the stats, but politically you'd be dead

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29914681

There's no reason hospitals can't still fill up anyway if you have enough volume.

EDIT: I should mention that I really appreciate what you said above:

> By the way, I also don't condone harassment of unvaccinated people or vaccination as a requirement for employment etc either. Those are separate issues to me.

Re:Pfizer board member suggests end to mask, vaccine mandates by srcreigh on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @02:47PM (#30090691)
I'm in Canada where the mandates are quite extensive but also change frequently.

I'd like to think the govt is hoping that each time restrictions are loosed, some type of immunity has developed and restrictionz can be loosed more. When things seem to get worse and worse again, the restrictions are added to ensure hospitals can work.

At the end of the day, a large decrease in severity will be the deciding factor. We can try to model when that will happen, but it will have to actually happen regardless of what the models say.

Re:Pfizer board member suggests end to mask, vaccine mandates by MatteoFrigo on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @02:57PM (#30090837)
https://covidestim.org/us has estimates on the percentage of people ever infected by state. I looked at MA, NY, and CA, and they all hover around 80% (with error bars). I can't find a cumulative US estimate.

I have no idea how they came up with the estimate, but the site is maintained by reputable institutions, so I am inclined to believe these numbers unless proven otherwise.

Re:Pfizer board member suggests end to mask, vaccine mandates by standardUser on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @07:55PM (#30094517)
Until the people hoarding ICU beds and grinding medical staff into the ground are no longer disproportionately unvaccinated COVID patients, I don't see anyone caring too much about the distinction.
Re:Pfizer board member suggests end to mask, vaccine mandates by ifyoubuildit on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @11:53PM (#30096372)
> ... I don't see anyone caring too much about the distinction.

I think you're absolutely right, which is why I'm here banging this drum. People should care about the distinction, because it matters if you want to actually understand the situation.

Certain groups are overrepresented in the prison system in the US. Some people think this means that all members of those groups are bad people. The people who think this are poorly informed, and can only get in the way of solving the actual problems.

And no, I'm not equating the treatment of unvaccinated people to that of minorities in the US. I am equating the structure of the misunderstanding involved (disadvantaged minority + other problems describes a lot of prisoners, but its the other problems that dominate the equation. Just like unvaccinated + seronaive can describe a hospitalized patient, but the seronaive part is what matters).

I tried to explain this better in another comment: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30096072

Re:Pfizer board member suggests end to mask, vaccine mandates by standardUser on Thursday January 27, 2022 @12:27AM (#30096575)
If the distinction is vaccinated people vs people with natural immunity, I don't think that's a scientifically sound distinction. Do you mean people who recovered 20 months ago from a long gone variant? Or people who recovered with no symptoms last week from Omicron? Do we know what it means if a person has antibodies from a recovery a year ago, given the advent of brand new strains that have spread like wildfire and are only just now being studied in depth?

What we do know, thanks to a mountain of unambiguous data, is that people who have had vaccine shots go to the hospital way, way, way less often than those who have not. Which means vaccines prevent other people from suffering bad health outcomes due to lack of healthcare resources. It is a win for everyone.

Re:Pfizer board member suggests end to mask, vaccine mandates by ifyoubuildit on Thursday January 27, 2022 @03:54AM (#30097958)
I'm not aware of any evidence of immunity after recovery waning over time. Omicron seems to infect more people with a previous infection than delta did, but protection from hospitalization is still strong. I'm interested to see otherwise if you have links.

The CDC looked at how people fared with delta with a previous diagnosis by March 2021, so presumably anywhere from when pcr and antigen tests started up until March. There is no breakdown of previous variants in this study, its just if you had a previous infection, you were protected.

I know, this doesn't sound like anything you've heard yet. They still manage to slip in a recommendation that "all eligible persons should be up to date with COVID-19 vaccination", but the data doesn't support that.

> Four cohorts of persons aged ≥18 years were assembled via linkages of records from electronic laboratory reporting databases and state-specific immunization information systems.† Persons were classified based on whether they had had a laboratory-confirmed SARS-CoV-2 infection by March 1, 2021 (i.e., previous COVID-19 diagnosis)§; had received at least the primary COVID-19 vaccination series¶ by May 16, 2021; had a previous COVID-19 diagnosis and were fully vaccinated*; or had neither received a previous COVID-19 diagnosis by March 1 nor received a first COVID-19 vaccine dose by the end of the analysis period.

> By the week beginning October 3, compared with COVID-19 cases rates among unvaccinated persons without a previous COVID-19 diagnosis, case rates among vaccinated persons without a previous COVID-19 diagnosis were 6.2-fold (California) and 4.5-fold (New York) lower; rates were substantially lower among both groups with previous COVID-19 diagnoses, including 29.0-fold (California) and 14.7-fold lower (New York) among unvaccinated persons with a previous diagnosis, and 32.5-fold (California) and 19.8-fold lower (New York) among vaccinated persons with a previous diagnosis of COVID-19. During the same period, compared with hospitalization rates among unvaccinated persons without a previous COVID-19 diagnosis, hospitalization rates in California followed a similar pattern. These results demonstrate that vaccination protects against COVID-19 and related hospitalization, and that surviving a previous infection protects against a reinfection and related hospitalization. Importantly, infection-derived protection was higher after the Delta variant became predominant, a time when vaccine-induced immunity for many persons declined because of immune evasion and immunologic waning (2,5,6).

Re:Pfizer board member suggests end to mask, vaccine mandates by yibg on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @02:10PM (#30090247)
How about we do this. For people that can and “should be” vaccinated but don’t by choice due to their own risk assessment, if they catch Covid and need hospital treatment they don’t get it.

That way they have their freedom and hospital capacity isn’t put at risk. If the people refusing to get vaccinated are willing to shoulder the risk themselves I have no problems with it.

Re:Pfizer board member suggests end to mask, vaccine mandates by ifyoubuildit on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @04:04PM (#30091811)
> If the people refusing to get vaccinated are willing to shoulder the risk themselves I have no problems with it.

This is the point: the people who are refusing to be vaccinated that have recovered from a prior infection are not at a higher risk of severe outcomes than the folks who got vaccinated and didn't have a previous infection [0].

So maybe if your definition of "should be vaccinated" is narrow enough, then maybe you can justify some kind of priority order for treatment. That's not a topic I'm going anywhere near though.

[0] https://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/volumes/71/wr/mm7104e1.htm?s_cid=mm...

Re:Pfizer board member suggests end to mask, vaccine mandates by yibg on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @05:28PM (#30093012)
There are going to be gray areas. Some individuals should not or cannot get the vaccine. What qualifies for that exactly is a bit muddy as well. So I agree what is "should" isn't very clear.

As an individual, it's really the numbers around the ratio of unvaccinated individuals in hospital / ICU consuming resources unnecessarily and therefore depleting them for the rest of us unnecessarily that's maddening. That plus the regrettable stories about people that are vocally anti-vax that end up dying from covid.

So for me it's like fine, freedom is important and you can choose to go against whatever recommendation you want. But at the same time you have to shoulder the consequences for it too. You can't have it both ways. Have the freedom to do whatever you want but also not bear the consequences of those actions.

Re:Pfizer board member suggests end to mask, vaccine mandates by ifyoubuildit on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @11:07PM (#30096072)
> As an individual, it's really the numbers around the ratio of unvaccinated individuals in hospital / ICU consuming resources unnecessarily and therefore depleting them for the rest of us unnecessarily that's maddening.

I think I'm failing to make this clear enough. I'll try again.

The set of unvaccinated people is made up of those with a prior infection (call them R for recovered) and without (call them N for naive). And for simplicity, we'll keep the vaccinated variable to a binary, yes or no. So you have vaccinated with a prior infection (VR) and vaccinated without (VN).

When you say unvaccinated you are talking about R + N. We have data from the CDC that says R and VN were at roughly equivalent risk of hospitalizatiom during delta, and VR was a little bit better. N was by far the worst, and is who you actually mean when you talk about the people disproportionately filling up the hospitals. Because that's what the CDC is saying, that members of R, VR, and VN were all showing up in the hospitals at a similar much lower rate, and N was in a different universe.

You wouldn't know this unless you specifically asked yourself the question and went looking for the answer, because so far it has gotten very little air time. So it's not surprising that you and lots of other people are not aware. I'm only aware because I happen to be a member of R, and so this is important to me. It sucks living in a world where lots of people think its fine to lump me in with N, and advocate for taking away my livelihood and freedom of movement.

Saying "the unvaccinated are clogging up the hospitals" is like saying "I don't like Mexican food" when really you just don't like spicy peppers. You may avoid some burn that way, but now you're missing out on the rest of the cuisine, and you've failed to equip yourself with the knowledge to avoid the Indian or Thai dishes that will destroy you (because you think it's just the Mexican part that matters, not the spicy ingredients).

Does that make sense?

Re:Pfizer board member suggests end to mask, vaccine mandates by yibg on Thursday January 27, 2022 @12:55PM (#30103725)
I think we're in agreement, and I wasn't being clear enough as well. I do mean the N set. This is what I mean by the "should" being fuzzy.

Unfortunately some of the R set ("some" is also fuzzy, I don't know how much but by this point I'm guessing high proportion), were in the N set and just didn't need to go to the hospital. So the mentality and risk factor prior to move from N to R is the same. There is no deterministic way (except moving to VN first) to mitigate that risk ahead of time.

Re:Pfizer board member suggests end to mask, vaccine mandates by acdha on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @06:02PM (#30093360)
It depends on what strain you had and timing — this paper had a previous infection lower than a 3 dose vaccination:

https://www.medrxiv.org/content/10.1101/2022.01.03.21268111v...

The big question, of course, is timing — if you had a mild case in 2020, you're unlikely to do as well as someone who got their second dose a couple months ago.

Re:Pfizer board member suggests end to mask, vaccine mandates by juiiiced on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @03:13PM (#30091056)
I agree. This is really the critical point: If you are in a low risk group, but get covid you have no way of knowing whether you will consume hospital resources or not. In that case it's best to get vaccinated if you can to protect others who made need the hospital.
Re:Pfizer board member suggests end to mask, vaccine mandates by Mountain_Skies on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @01:22PM (#30089500)
Recognizing that naturally acquired immunity exists for tens of millions isn't the same thing as encouraging people to intentionally catch covid to gain natural immunity. Failure to differentiate between the two is just another way the injection maximalists look out of touch or unempathetic.
Re:Pfizer board member suggests end to mask, vaccine mandates by spookthesunset on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @03:35PM (#30091396)
> Encouraging natural immunity is asking for hospitals to get filled up by people giving themselves covid on purpose. This affects non covid patients too.

So uh, what is that.... 0.01% of the entire population? Less? Yes, some people will cheat the system but people cheat all systems all the time. That's just life.

Most people will do the right thing. We cannot build a society around 0.01% of us who cheat.

Re:Pfizer board member suggests end to mask, vaccine mandates by loudtieblahblah on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @02:14PM (#30090293)
Yeah all those Oklahoma gunshot victims can't be seen by the ER.

https://taibbi.substack.com/p/moral-majority-media-strikes-a...

Re:Pfizer board member suggests end to mask, vaccine mandates by smnrchrds on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @01:18PM (#30089430)
That's also why many governments do not accept proof of recovery in lieu of proof of vaccination. Those who do have vaccine-skeptic people catching the virus intentionally and risking death.

https://globalnews.ca/news/8524409/hana-horka-czech-singer-c...

Re:Pfizer board member suggests end to mask, vaccine mandates by eggy on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @01:38PM (#30089748)
So there playing the I am ignoring it or lying about it for your benefit card like Fauci about masks early on?

It was a while ago that the CDC estimated recovered COVID numbers to bre around 146 million. It is more like over 200 million at this point with overlap of vaccinated people.

I am sick of being ignored of having recovered, and people making the excuse that if they let us know how good natural immunity is, or even talk about it, the idiots will go out and get COVID. I don't want a nanny state, or police state for that matter. The WHO and a lot of the world are at odds with the CDC especially on masking and boosting of under 12 year-olds.

Besides boosting one after the other may be weakening the immune system [1]. It makes sense. It raises antibodies, but wanes quickly. Natural immunity lives in B- and T-cell long-term memory of the immune system. SARS-COV1 recovered are still testing strong for immunity for over 18 years now.

I am getting repetitive, but let's address obesity, diabetes, poor lifestyle choices, and their kind before mandating anyone's personal health choices or shaming them for their decisions. If I call out obesity it is fat shaming..., but go ahead and lump the recovered in with the unvaccinated and try and shame and steer the course of our lives with mandates and policing.

[1] https://newsrescue.com/covid-boosters-could-weaken-immune-sy...

Re:Pfizer board member suggests end to mask, vaccine mandates by Daishiman on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @05:39PM (#30093117)
The difference is that I can't catch diabetes or obesity from others.
Re:Pfizer board member suggests end to mask, vaccine mandates by eggy on Wednesday February 09, 2022 @12:25PM (#30275303)
No, those are self-inflicted, and you can take action to rid yourself of them or minimize their effects. Self empowerment.

And since I first posted the CDC released a study that shows natural immunity is better than vaccination. Not surprised since vaccination went from 95% efficacy, and you will not catch or transmit COVID (very early on); to well, it's like 78% effective after a few months, and you can catch a mild case of COVID; to it drops below 50% after 3 to 5 months (vaccines cannot be FDA approved if they show less than 50% effectiveness), and you will need a booster, and you can be infected and infect others.

And we can debate mask-wearing, but there are no substantive studies on the issue, and if naturally immune and the vaccinated are protected (probably greater than 90% of the population by now), why masks? Not to even drag in having all of our children masked 8 hours/day, while the rest of us are able to limit our mask-wearing even though 12 and under are the least at risk for anything serious from COVID.

Re:Pfizer board member suggests end to mask, vaccine mandates by Mountain_Skies on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @01:25PM (#30089554)
Yes, yet another way the government is dishonestly manipulating people into a single course of action even when it is of little benefit to anyone other than those who mistake metrics for what the metrics were designed to manage. There appears to be no bottom to the depths of credibility destruction that the government will plunge in order to put compliance above all else.
Re:Pfizer board member suggests end to mask, vaccine mandates by walterbell on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @01:24PM (#30089532)
Let's remember that the best case for vaccinated people is Covid recovery. Wilful ignorance of the best case would be unwise.

https://cbs12.com/news/local/new-covid-variant-detected-in-a...

> "Omicron is acting like a super booster," Unnasch said. "People who have gotten omicron are going to be really well protected against infection, not just disease moving forward, which is a really good sign."

Re:Pfizer board member suggests end to mask, vaccine mandates by smnrchrds on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @01:44PM (#30089866)
The best case is never catching COVID again. Even vaccinated people put themselves at risk (albeit less than non-vaccinated people) if they catch COVID intentionally. No one recommends just going out there and catching COVID. But when proof of vaccination systems allow for it, some people do it anyway and some of them die instead.

Relevant xkcd: https://xkcd.com/2557/

Re:Pfizer board member suggests end to mask, vaccine mandates by walterbell on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @01:47PM (#30089918)
Not going to happen with a coronavirus, even with self-isolation forever.
Re:Pfizer board member suggests end to mask, vaccine mandates by propogandist on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @07:11PM (#30094123)
>Encouraging natural immunity is asking for hospitals to get filled up by people giving themselves covid on purpose.

there's no interest in talking about actual treatments or a $1 early treatment remedy [1], like every other disease. There's nothing that's patentable and profitable, so the focus is on vaccinations, which increasingly show more infections

The US DoD maintains detailed military personnel data to protect national security. Their health care surveillance data shows everything from neurological issues impacting US airforce pilots to 300% increase in miscarriages and cancer. The data is being scrubbed and military whistleblowers are trying to fight to bring it to public attention.

It's like Snowden, but from the healthcare department of the US military. [2]

1 - https://c19early.com -- w/ peer reviewed data sources

2-https://twitter.com/TheChiefNerd/status/1485695818996854788

Re:Pfizer board member suggests end to mask, vaccine mandates by walterbell on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @08:01PM (#30094570)
Thank you for posting.