Re:A trick to have arbitrary infix operators in Python
by rocqua on Friday January 28, 2022 @06:06AM
(#30113148)
I think multiplication for string concatenation makes more sense than just "its juxtaposition so we call it multiplication". If you look at type theory, then a tuple of type (A, B) is called the product type of A and B. This is because there are #A times #B elements in the new type. A Sum type, in type theory is a tagged union. It is an element of Either A or B. (Like a C union with an extra tag saying which type it contains). This is a sum because it contains #A plus #B elements.
Concatenation of strings is much closer to the tuple approach. And the argument about the number of elements in the type still holds if you keep the string-length fixed.
1. juxtaposition is shorter than any alternative and hence a natural choice for the most common / only operation on the set in question
2. the operation is roughly analogous to function composition, and when you apply two composed functions it looks like f(g(x)) with f and g juxtaposed (if the functions are among those that have the longest history of being written as prefix operators, e.g. sin, cos, log, you don't even need the paren between the f and the g)
3. juxtaposition is a natural way to express an operation which is just "putting stuff together", such as string concatenation
So while it makes sense to denote string concatenation by juxtaposition in mathematics, I think it's a bit of a leap to go from there to say that A * B is the right notation for a programming language. (Actually using juxtaposition would be fine, but a general-purpose programming language is likely to want to reserve juxtaposition for something else.)
Also if you run with the idea that string concatenation = putting two strings together, well, addition is sort of like putting two numbers together. Rephrasing that in mathematical language: natural numbers can be encoded as elements of the free monoid on one generator, in which case the monoid operation turns out to be addition. I think that might be why the A + B notation is preferred over A * B when we have to choose one or the other.