It felt like cheap plastic crap too (imo).
The iPhone 5 was the first iOS phone with turn by turn nav and LTE which were the reasons I stuck with the Nexus phones as each one got worse. The 5's battery life was also ridiculously good in comparison and the hardware design holds up even now ten years later.
The HTC Nexus One was the best of the first three, I'm not sure why Samsung gets so much love for hardware. The Nexus S and Galaxy Nexus builds were both ugly and poor. The Nokia N9 was beautiful and I was bummed when Microsoft turned them into windows only devices, they would have been great android phones.
That was another thing at the time which pushed me away from android, they didn't have control over their OS because of this lack of control over hardware.
It was a little like Windows and all the crap that came installed on it, except worse because you couldn't even reset it.