"What's the most exciting project you've worked on?"
"What's your most exciting vacation?"
If I haven't already considered the case for such interview/icebreaker questions, I just don't tend to remember things on that axis since most of them kind of clump together around the origin. So if I want to even try and give an answer they were looking for, I have to do a random search through a bunch of memories and guess at levels. Or default to the first thing I remember regardless.
The irony is i can and have gotten extremely excited (mostly when i am not recalling anything similar) in the past, but found that it is a disappointment almost always. So nowadays, i try to recall similar things and try to see the differences.
I was just told the same thing at a big company. I'm sorry, but I thought I was hired to develop good software, not be on a cheerleading squad. My mistake.
Edit: He had used 'baritone and coldly logical', I think.
Age helps with self control. I improved my emotional range by taking acting lessons in the Meisner technique.
My natural voice used to be flat and emotionless. It might have had something to do with my family life or with how I adapted to getting picked on in elementary school.
I've learned to put more range in my voice and I think it helps everywhere from work to flirting (I can't say dating since I'm a family man.) I used to be terrified of job interviews and now I'm not. It's opened up a whole new world for me.
While its nice to know many others in this thread and the article experience the same personality traits, I think its important for us not to use that as an excuse not to communicate better with others!
He got me. He knew that I -could- get excited, when there was cause to. But just because every day is normal and not horrible is no reason to act excited.
> Me: "um. indeed."
That's just extreme politeness, not a lack of excitement.
There's also the problem that I express myself much better in writing than verbally. This is definitely a problem I'm working on, but many times when I start talking about something I'm passionate about I feel like I'm making a hash of the explanation and not doing it justice, or worse sounding like a bs'er.
Point being, don't take a perceived lack of enthusiasm for actual lack of enthusiasm (or more pertinent, lack of dedication). Even though Americans are taught to 'express yourself' wily-nily, there can be lots of reasons why some of us may not. Try to see past that, don't hold it against us.
Worse than being merely off-putting, I think it actively hurts, personally and professionally, when your don't get as excited over every little thing as your peers. People take it as a sign of indifference, and judge you for not being a "team player" or other such nonsense.
I long ago learned that it's always best to keep your mouth shut rather than saying negative things in public (though it can certainly be a lot less fun). But the little trap that no one warns you about is that it's possible to be perceived as negative simply by being less enthusiastic than baseline. And it drives me nuts when people put me into positions where my only option is to feign enthusiasm, or to say something negative:
Rude Person: "isn't Yanni just the most brilliant musician ever? And how about that Kenny G -- jazz will never be the same, right?"
Me: "um. indeed."
This kind of stuff happens all the time, and it never gets any easier to navigate.