News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:NFT: even more deceiving by 8note on Monday January 24, 2022 @05:49PM (#30065185)
How do those handle DMCA takedowns?
Re:NFT: even more deceiving by vmception on Monday January 24, 2022 @05:56PM (#30065264)
It wouldn't?

I'm not sure the question? An NFT with no reliance on third party infrastructure, as described above, would have no ability for denial of service. More analogous to a non-digital art piece, where only third party individuals or companies that are digitally presenting an existing piece could be coerced by the arm of the state to stop displaying it via a DMCA request, but the existing piece still exists for anyone physically present to see. The NFT would just transcend geography in this case.

So a marketplace like OpenSea or a digital gallery could potentially receive a DMCA request. Galleries with unknown owners are likely going to become more prevalent.

It's up to the communities and potential purchasers to be discerning about what they interact with or buy, not really a standard to place on the technology thats a higher standard than other media. NFTs aren't here to solve plagiarism and unauthorized distribution. For a previous NFT work being re-released by someone else, consumers should check with the official community first before trying to acquire that contract. For an NFT work that wasn't previously issued (like a famous artist putting their stuff onchain suddenly now), they should do greater due diligence.

Re:NFT: even more deceiving by peoplefromibiza on Monday January 24, 2022 @06:40PM (#30065756)
so basically we should throw away millennia of history and trial and error to reboot our societies using a technology that doesn't even work without an internet connection and a very fast computing device?
Re:NFT: even more deceiving by vmception on Monday January 24, 2022 @06:46PM (#30065825)
the DMCA is 24 years old and its current use relies on an internet connection more heavily than onchain NFTs do. what stimuli were you replying to exactly, its not clear to me.
Re:NFT: even more deceiving by peoplefromibiza on Monday January 24, 2022 @06:49PM (#30065843)
the DMCA relies on something called a law and the power of the State to enforce such law, using the force if necessary.

your suggestion is to give up centuries of refinements on law making/enforcement and rely on personally checking every single trnsaction, because if you don't and are scammed, you're screwed and there's nothing you can do to get your money back.

I'm not sure it's an improvement.

Re:NFT: even more deceiving by vmception on Monday January 24, 2022 @06:58PM (#30065923)
This thread isn't about NFTs being an improvement over all copyrighted work, this thread is about NFTs being an improvement over other NFTs.

On the consumer side I wasn't suggesting anything, I said what they have to do in response to an already existing market with already existing transactions. This isn't about some future reality we imagine on an internet forum, this is about one you are simply not in.

If you think checking is too hard, then make a service that makes it easier to check and charge people for it, how often do you rule out business models that you personally identify, because thats what the market is saying to do.

Re:NFT: even more deceiving by peoplefromibiza on Monday January 24, 2022 @07:04PM (#30065982)
> If you think checking is too hard

I'm saying it is useless

Who's the authority that certifies that I am the real aithor of the NFT I'm selling?

And what the original author can do to prevent it?

absolutely nothing.

so it's completely useless.

you're buying random numbers produced by running some computing device at 100% for a few hours/days

would you buy the output of 'cat /dev/urandom'?

Re:NFT: even more deceiving by miracle2k on Monday January 24, 2022 @08:45PM (#30066833)
It's a spreadsheet that is a list of tokens created by artists, and the corresponding owner in the column to the right. That spreadsheet will survive the bankruptcy of any particular company, which gives the tokens a sense of permanence, and Benjaminian aura if you will, that you don't get from a ledger run by Google.

That is what is is, that is what people find it useful for. It is not supposed to do any other things.

Re:NFT: even more deceiving by peoplefromibiza on Tuesday January 25, 2022 @05:44AM (#30070379)
> It's a spreadsheet that is a list of tokens created by artists

or by people that found something slightly interesting and put it on the blockchain for money.

here's no assurance that some artist made it, there's no assurance the author is the one selling it, there's basically no assurance, apart that they are trying to trick people into thinking that it's an investment.

It's, in other words, a scam.

> That spreadsheet will survive the bankruptcy of any particular company

It won't.

Monuments in Rome have survived thousands of years and hundreds of wars.

98% of NFTs will last at max few months

> that you don't get from a ledger run by Google

at least I can sue Google if they publish on their ledger the hash of something I made and someone else sold without my permission...

> That is what is is, that is what people find it useful for

Please, don't try to sell me your snake oil.

That's the opposite of why people want them.

People absolutely don't care about the item, proof is that the majority of items sold as NFTs would never ever have a market outside of the speculative bubble (and in fact they never had one before).

Re:NFT: even more deceiving by miracle2k on Tuesday January 25, 2022 @02:22PM (#30076664)
> here's no assurance that some artist made it

Correct. I do not see how it follows that a NFT minted by the artist who made it is a scam.

> 98% of NFTs will last at max few months

You make this mistake because you think the url matters. It does not. It is the collectors job to ensure the art survives. Agreement on what the token represents, either ad-hoc or through a hash is enough.

> at least I can sue Google if they publish on their ledger the hash of something I made and someone else sold without my permission...

True.

> People absolutely don't care about the item, proof is that the majority of items sold as NFTs would never ever have a market outside of the speculative bubble (and in fact they never had one before).

There is a speculative bubble, but art will remain hard to sell the less it is a short-term speculative investment, but the creation of this previously non-existent market is indeed the contribution here. Without the market, the spreadsheet is not interesting.

Re:NFT: even more deceiving by peoplefromibiza on Thursday January 27, 2022 @09:39AM (#30101082)
> It is the collectors job to ensure the art survives

it doesn't make any sense in this context

of course if I buy a painting i am responsible to maintain the painting, but the painting It's the item I bough!

here you're buying the URL, the only way to keep it working is taking over the maintenance of someone else's server, but only for that specific URL

Or I have to pay and there's no limit on how much it would cost

If i move the item to another URL, _it would be indistinguable from the billions of possible exact replicas_

hence NFTs provide no value at all

> There is a speculative bubble, but art will remain hard to sell the less it is a short-term speculative investment

art has a value if I can put it on display

Re:NFT: even more deceiving by miracle2k on Sunday January 30, 2022 @08:17AM (#30136916)
> here you're buying the URL

But you aren't buying the URL, your are buying a ledger entry that represents an artwork, and there happens to be a URL attached for your convenience.

> The only way to keep it working is taking over the maintenance of someone else's server, but only for that specific URL

IPFS fits neatly in here. Anyone can seed a particular file they want to seed.

Re:NFT: even more deceiving by StanislavPetrov on Monday January 24, 2022 @08:26PM (#30066675)
>your suggestion is to give up centuries of refinements on law making/enforcement

Some of us would use a different and much less flattering term than "refinement" to describe the centuries of "evolution" of law and law enforcement.

Re:NFT: even more deceiving by peoplefromibiza on Tuesday January 25, 2022 @05:29AM (#30070281)
> Some of us would use a different and much less flattering term than "refinement"

you can use whatever term you like, it's been a refinement process nonetheless.