Re:Be Careful when Speaking to Federal Agents - 18 U.S.C. Se...
by jackpirate on Friday September 16, 2011 @10:44PM
(#3007077)
I think that is not true in general. Consider, for example, the charge of reckless driving.
I think (although have no data) that there are probably more laws requiring human judgment than are based on strictly numerical criteria. Off the top of my head, the various degrees of murder, perjury, hate crimes, divorce settlements, and probate court. These all may have very specific criteria to meet them, but there is no way an algorithm could determine innocence or guilt.
The only numerical laws I can think of are speed limits and the lines between grand theft / theft.
Re:Be Careful when Speaking to Federal Agents - 18 U.S.C. Se...
by shabble on Friday September 16, 2011 @08:10PM
(#3006800)
A good test might be, "if every single person obeyed this law strictly as it is written, would society still operate the way we intend?" (c.f. https://secure.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/wiki/Work-to-rule )
I don't know how this can be fixed though. At the moment we have to rely on judges to save us from the precision of the law, and we all know that judges can be just as corrupt/resentful/bored/petty as the rest of us.