Re:The Free and Open Source Silicon Foundation
by kragen on Monday January 24, 2022 @05:05PM
(#30064701)
I thought it was the Artistic License which required modifications to be distributed in patch form? The FSF does seem to have considered the original Artistic License to be non-free.
I think there was some disagreement about some version of the Apache License too, but I think it was about whether it was GPL-compatible, not about whether it was free.
The primary difference between "Open Source" and "Free Software" is political. The FSF was explicitly a political organization to promote Stallman's idea of software freedom[1] while the OSI was created specifically to make an "apolitical" business case for it. This means a lot for advocacy and ideology but not so much for the actual rules of what you can copy and when.
Also, Apache license is both OSI and FSF approved. The main problem is that you cannot combine GPLv2 and Apache software. This is only a problem if you don't want to take GPLv3's TiVo clause and/or blocked v3 upgrades.
[0] If I remember correctly, there's one license that requires modifications be distributed in patch form, which satisfies DFSG/OSI but not FSD.
[1] To the point of writing a documentation license, GFDL, that prohibits you from removing Stallman's rants on free software, which ironically makes it non-Free.