News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Be Careful when Speaking to Federal Agents - 18 U.S.C. Se... by marshray on Friday September 16, 2011 @02:57PM (#3005782)
People I know who have run internet startups have had contact with federal agents on various occasions.

EDIT. This response is getting so many upvotes I'm going to clarify it a bit, particularly for people who may be reading this from other countries:

Yes, you can start and run a business in America without ever having direct interaction with the US Federal Government, other than mailing off your taxes. It's not like every business one day gets a visit from the KGB and they tell you to do things a certain way (or else).

Nevertheless, if you are for example an ISP or provide messaging, as you grow big enough it's probably a matter of time before you'll end up getting a subscriber who's being investigated. You may have a former employee that goes on to apply for some sort of special security clearance and they follow up on his background (or you go out of your way to hire a talented hacker with a mysterious background). You may simply meet such agents due to ordinary shared interests, like say at a trade show or a conference. Of course, you could also meet them when they are also actually investigating something with the aim of prosecuting people.

I don't know which of these situations fall under the law described in the article, possibly all of them do.

Re:Be Careful when Speaking to Federal Agents - 18 U.S.C. Se... by BrandonM on Friday September 16, 2011 @06:21PM (#3006560)
> if you are for example an ISP or provide messaging, as you grow big enough it's probably a matter of time before you'll end up getting a subscriber who's being investigated

That is not what Hacker News is for. If your company is that big, you should have counsel on retainer, and they should be advising you of the proper behavior in the face of potential federal investigation. Moreover, it's our job as American citizens to be aware of our legal exposure and to know the proper way to proceed. It's a shame that this is not taught in our high school Government courses.

It is not the role of Hacker News to educate us on these issues. There are other sites for that. You can tell by the quality of the comment thread that it's not something that appeals to "our inner hacker." An article is not HN material simply by appealing to some (or even a majority) of the members here; it must satisfy other criteria, and this one does not.