Re:IBM’s Watson Health is sold off in parts
by umanwizard on Monday January 24, 2022 @10:40AM
(#30058976)
> It uses heuristics to assign values to different board states, and in the case of Deep Blue these values were created through previous game analysis.
Unless I’m misinformed, this part isn’t true. The heuristic was hardcoded with the help of human experts.
Re:IBM’s Watson Health is sold off in parts
by Phillipharryt on Monday January 24, 2022 @06:30PM
(#30065662)
From the paper Deep Blue by Murray Campbell et al (people who worked on Deep Blue)
"The initialization of the feature values is done by the “evaluation function generator”, a
sub-program which was run on the master node of SP system." Which would suggest it generated the heuristic itself. The features may have been hardcoded, but assigning values to them wasn't.
In addition to this, feature values could be static or dynamic, meaning it would update dynamic ones depending on the board state. It not only generated the heuristic values (feature values) it could modify them to reflect their relative change in impact throughout the game.
Chess is not a solved game from the starting state, so it has to make assumptions based on the data it has. This is machine learning. Please don't make such definite statements. You even say it in your own comment "selects the best possible true of outcomes", how do you think it selects this? It uses heuristics to assign values to different board states, and in the case of Deep Blue these values were created through previous game analysis. If a knight to c2 on turn 8 is rarely seen in the same game as a winning board state, then this is valued lower. Looking through the tree wasn't the ML part, but knowing how to pick the best node on the tree was. Deep Blue is ML.