Literally half the teachers thought it was cheating and I should be punished, whilst the other half thought (because I hadn't abused it to win prizes) that it showed a creative use of more modern skills to make up for my renowned weak mental-math.
I saw the joy in writing the solver as much more interesting than the math. Same way I can't focus on sudoku given I always try to "solve" solving it.
In fact, simply the act of creating an infallible solver (100% likelihood of 6 guesses or less) demonstrates the futility of competing with their soft, fleshy skills.
I do think any solver that uses the solution-set is "cheating", but I suspect it makes little difference in the total solution (like... 2-3 bits of additional information needed, just a fraction of a round).
You could either compete on number of guesses. Or you could fix the hardware (eg a Famicom), and compete on runtime?