Re:Myths about cooking steak that need to go away (2013)
by gruez on Saturday January 22, 2022 @06:59PM
(#30042162)
I fail to see how a circulator is more convenient or effortless. For starters you need to prep a bag and a pot of water if you're using a circulator. On the other hand with reverse sear all you need to do is stick a thermometer in, throw it on a pan/rack and put it in an oven. After you're done with the circulator you have to wrangle with a wet bag full of beef liquid and dry off the steak (otherwise your sear will be impaired). With reverse sear you can take it directly from the oven to the pan. During the sear stage, the timing you need is minimal for both. You only need to get the pan as hot as you can get it, and sear both sides until it's charred to your liking.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Myths about cooking steak that need to go away (2013)
by burntsushi on Saturday January 22, 2022 @09:51PM
(#30043162)
I don't really understand how you can "fail" to see the convenience. The convenience comes from the ease of getting it right. I consistently over-cooked steaks with the reverse sear method. Maybe half the time. With sous vide, I never---literally never---overcook a steak.
That's the convenience. I don't have to worry about the temperature. I drop it in the bath and I take it out at my convenience.
Re:Myths about cooking steak that need to go away (2013)
by tptacek on Saturday January 22, 2022 @11:09PM
(#30043556)
I'm interested in what tended to go wrong for you with the reverse sear. One tricky thing is that the temperature increases nonlinearly, so if you take a couple readings and get a mental trajectory of when it's going to hit 115, you're likely to be wrong. The flip side though is that cooking at 250 (or, sheesh, 200, as they're doing across the thread) gives you a _real big bulls-eye_ to hit.
Nobody's gonna say that a circulator steak is bad. It's the second-best way to cook a steak. :)
Re:Myths about cooking steak that need to go away (2013)
by gruez on Saturday January 22, 2022 @11:31PM
(#30043642)
>so if you take a couple readings and get a mental trajectory of when it's going to hit 115, you're likely to be wrong
I just keep a thermometer in for the entire duration of the bake time. Someone in this thread posted a screenshot of them doing the same thing with some sort of bluetooth thermometer.
Re:Myths about cooking steak that need to go away (2013)
by burntsushi on Sunday January 23, 2022 @07:23AM
(#30045639)
It's been years since I tried it. So I don't remember precisely. I'm not a good cook. :-) It was just very easy for me to overshoot it.
Re:Myths about cooking steak that need to go away (2013)
by stickfigure on Sunday January 23, 2022 @01:22AM
(#30044060)
If you buy whole or fractional cow, the butcher will typically hand you boxes of separately vac-sealed cuts. At that point, it's really hard to beat the convenience of "grab one, throw it in the circulator". You don't even need to defrost it.
Re:Myths about cooking steak that need to go away (2013)
by fisherjeff on Saturday January 22, 2022 @11:58PM
(#30043760)
For me, the convenience is that you can prep the bag and pot long before doing anything else. It’s not necessarily less work, just better distributed IMO