News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How bad is QWERTY, really? A review of the literature, su... by userbinator on Friday January 21, 2022 @08:11PM (#30032095)
Personal anecdote, but I know a few people who got RSI/CTS and had a chance to watch them type --- and what they all had in common was how "stiff" their typing posture was, and the strength at which they hit the keys. They weren't fast either, probably in the 50-70wpm range. One of them, before he got RSI, even commented on how bad my posture was and how it'd "make it easier to injure myself".

I find that relaxing, as counterintuitive as it may sound at first, actually helps with typing speed and comfort. To me it makes sense that if you tense up all your muscles and punch the keys really hard, you're much more likely to injure yourself, slow down, and tire more quickly. I think the vast majority of keyboards also have too high of an actuation force, which also adds to the strain of typing. If you look at videos of fast typists (150wpm+), they don't look like they're exerting much effort at all; many of them aren't using the "standard" key-to-finger mapping, and a lot of them "smear" their hands all over the keyboard. Here's one example (not me):

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Y4NUqoXI8Xw

Re:How bad is QWERTY, really? A review of the literature, su... by _fat_santa on Friday January 21, 2022 @08:28PM (#30032192)
Back when I was still an intern, I noticed that i was getting wrist pain and was instantly worries about getting carpel tunnel later so I went out and got a Microsoft Ergonomic keyboard.

I've since stuck with them and one of the things that I love about them is how they force you to use more of your fingers because it restricts what keys each hand has access to. I found that the way I typed changed, the 't', 'g', 'r' and 'f' keys I could no longer reach over with my left hand and vice versa for the other hand. This meant I had to switch my how I typed which inevitably switched which fingers I used to hit some fingers and forced me to use more of my hand for the typing (the "smear" as you call it)

Re:How bad is QWERTY, really? A review of the literature, su... by ordu on Saturday January 22, 2022 @01:46AM (#30034337)
> they all had in common was how "stiff" their typing posture was, and the strength at which they hit the keys.

Yeah! Its what I want to be researched. I play piano and guitar, and to do it successfully I had spent a lot of time learning to not apply more force than needed. Somtimes it needs to change a posture. I learned piano being a kid under a supervision of a teacher, so probably I don't remember the most of my learning troubles. But I learned guitar at my late teens and I remember clearly how I was corrected by a teacher, then corrected again and again. I oftentimes needed a break because of pain in muscles.

And I wonder might it be that in the most cases RSI is the consequences of the wrong posture or too much force applied. If it so, I suppose, switching layouts would help because of breaking a muscle memory and learning it anew, not because the new layout is better. The very RSI could influence learning: pain is a good teacher, it forces student to seek for painless ways to do things.

Re:How bad is QWERTY, really? A review of the literature, su... by jmcdl on Saturday January 22, 2022 @12:11AM (#30033814)
Much like a virtuoso pianist really. Tension is the number one enemy for a pianist. It leads to injuries and more importantly, bad music.

This is a nice video of some elite level relaxed hands: https://youtu.be/Ray6knVCsp8?t=115

Re:How bad is QWERTY, really? A review of the literature, su... by jacobmartin on Saturday January 22, 2022 @12:31AM (#30033948)
I am a pianist and have spent years trying to eliminate tension. It's a lifelong effort! But so worth it.

I recently saw a video of a concerto by cellist Bruno Philippe and was astonished to see how loosely he appeared to be holding the bow. It almost appeared that it would slip at any moment. Yet he was in total control and his tone was perfect!

Re:How bad is QWERTY, really? A review of the literature, su... by opan on Saturday January 22, 2022 @04:09PM (#30040858)
I'm just gonna say that as someone typing 120+wpm for years now, I hate to see high actuation force vilified like this. It's my preference and I quite enjoy the higher force needed. Fewer accidental presses, and you can even lightly drum on your keys without them activating, which is fun and relaxing.

I went from cherry mx blues to cherry mx greens to kailh box navies and I love them to pieces.

I find that the people who swear by very light linear switches rarely type as fast as me, take that as you will. I think they fell down a strange rabbit hole.

Re:How bad is QWERTY, really? A review of the literature, su... by userbinator on Sunday January 23, 2022 @05:34AM (#30045138)
The observation comes from my personal experience that actuation force seems to be almost directly proportional to typing speed and how long it takes to get tired. Maybe those with heavier fingers and/or stronger muscles would prefer a heavier keyfeel.

My fastest typing has been done on a ~40g rubber dome that actuates quite close to the top, and then has a very springy "cushion" past that (contrary to a lot of "common wisdom", they don't have to go all the way down to actuate --- that's what the "tit" on the bottom of the dome is for, and the longer and softer it is, the more cushion you get). Definitely not linear, but the bump is very subtle.

As for my speed: I can sustain around 150-160 for long periods, with brief (~10 second) bursts over 200.