Re:Roosevelt Statue Removed from Natural-History Museum for ...
by tptacek on Friday January 21, 2022 @01:48PM
(#30028138)
I don't think this is really true at all.
Roosevelt's elevation above the lesser races and cultures, and by extension the elevation of Roosevelt's culture, was the intent of the sculpture. Fraser was by no account a virulent racist --- he'd spent time out in the frontier west, and was apparently deeply sympathetic towards Native Americans (he's also the designer of the Buffalo nickel!). But he's unmistakably building on the idea of Native Americans as members of a defeated culture, celebrated in their pacified decline and allowed to quietly vanish off the Earth.
Again: we don't so much have to guess about the ideas captured in this work; lots has been written about it. It's modeled after a Renaissance sculpture depicting a ruthless mercenary general. It depicts something like a Roman Triumph --- which, notably, Roosevelt actually held at his inauguration, with conquered Native American chiefs marching to celebrate his victory --- long before the Amazon expedition.
I think a problem you're running into here is that you're evaluating Roosevelt and not the statue. I'm sure there's someone who wants to get rid of the Equestrian Teddy because they hate Teddy, but for the most part, the problem is with the sculpture itself and what it's saying, not with some historical assessment of Roosevelt himself.
Roosevelt's elevation above the lesser races and cultures, and by extension the elevation of Roosevelt's culture, was the intent of the sculpture. Fraser was by no account a virulent racist --- he'd spent time out in the frontier west, and was apparently deeply sympathetic towards Native Americans (he's also the designer of the Buffalo nickel!). But he's unmistakably building on the idea of Native Americans as members of a defeated culture, celebrated in their pacified decline and allowed to quietly vanish off the Earth.
Again: we don't so much have to guess about the ideas captured in this work; lots has been written about it. It's modeled after a Renaissance sculpture depicting a ruthless mercenary general. It depicts something like a Roman Triumph --- which, notably, Roosevelt actually held at his inauguration, with conquered Native American chiefs marching to celebrate his victory --- long before the Amazon expedition.
I think a problem you're running into here is that you're evaluating Roosevelt and not the statue. I'm sure there's someone who wants to get rid of the Equestrian Teddy because they hate Teddy, but for the most part, the problem is with the sculpture itself and what it's saying, not with some historical assessment of Roosevelt himself.