Re:NASA: Tonga blast was 10 megatons, more powerful than a n...
by runarberg on Thursday January 20, 2022 @06:13PM
(#30016743)
It is relevant because if we are dealing with a poisson-like distribution the chances of the event happening is greater over a longer time-span. We don’t know what distribution nuclear strikes and accidents occur with. It may very well be a distribution similar to Russian roulette. If it is, we really really shouldn’t risk it any further.
That is the flaw in your logic. It is assuming a favorable distribution when the distribution is unknown.
In the MAD game, both the goal and the incentives are rationally aligned to avoid pulling the trigger at all. If MAD fails, it will happen because a mistake occurred. If the "Just let the UN take care of it" approach fails, it will fail for the same reason it has failed so many times before: because someone rationally calculated that the consequences were worth it. These scenarios don't really compare to a simple game of Russian roulette.
Logically speaking, it seems best to keep doing what we've been doing, but work as hard as we can to reduce the odds of a mistake.