News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Arm releases experimental CHERI-enabled Morello board by plutonorm on Thursday January 20, 2022 @12:04PM (#30011573)
Exactly - these formal methods have implicit assumptions in them. Within their axioms/priors they are proven correct. But the devil is in those assumptions. And that is disregarding the rather foggy notion of 'proof'. Is this proof written in a formal proof system that automates the proof? Because if it isn't you have another source of error. Even if it is in a formal proof system, who is to say that there is no error in the formal proof system? I admit that each layer adds more assurance - but appealing to 'formal proof' is a bit like appealing to god, it's an appeal to an unassailable authority. When in fact, once you know the details these things are never so clear cut.

There are no comments on this comment yet.