News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Are We Really Engineers? (2021) by Godel_unicode on Thursday January 20, 2022 @01:23AM (#30005480)
> we call them civil engineers.

We do not. Civil engineer is a specific thing, with training, education, and licensing. The person who designed the system being installed or serviced was likely a civil engineer, the plumber is a plumber. And that's ok, everyone doesn't have to be an engineer. Being an engineer isn't inherently better than being a non-engineer.

> an engineer as someone who uses fundamental principles and processes of science and engineering

Do you see how saying an engineer is someone who does engineering isn't useful to other people? I'm sure you know what you mean, but basically everyone is and is not an engineer according to your definition.

Re:Are We Really Engineers? (2021) by throwawayboise on Thursday January 20, 2022 @01:55AM (#30005648)
A plumber with enough experience can do engineer-y things, e.g. design an appropriate plumbing system for a house or renovation.

Or a plumber can just be a guy following a plan and cutting and gluing pipes together.

Re:Are We Really Engineers? (2021) by bumby on Saturday January 22, 2022 @11:53AM (#30038320)
But they cannot stamp a design, meaning it's not legal (depending on scope and permitting requirements). I can tell a person what ails them if they give me a list of symptoms but that shouldn't be conflated with me practicing medicine as a doctor. An HVAC technician can lay out a design for, say an operating room, but a licensed engineer is the only one who can stamp it saying it meets standards for ventilation. This where the fuzzy terms of "engineer-y" can get us into trouble. ~engineerish != engineer
Re:Are We Really Engineers? (2021) by balls187 on Thursday January 20, 2022 @01:29PM (#30012668)
> We do not. Civil engineer is a specific thing, with training, education, and licensing.

Yes. That is the joke (among non-civil engineers with civil engineer friends).

> Do you see how saying an engineer is someone who does engineering isn't useful to other people?

No. Because that is not what I wrote.

I also provided a concrete problem, along with an engineering and non-engineering approach to solving it.