News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Millionaires group calls for wealth tax at virtual Davos by antisthenes on Wednesday January 19, 2022 @06:09PM (#30001803)
I wanted to disagree with your post, but after giving it some thought, I believe that you're right.

People will simply start to shift their wealth into areas that are loophole advantaged or hide it altogether in trusts, relatives and even something as banal as precious metals under the pillow.

It will never work.

Re:Millionaires group calls for wealth tax at virtual Davos by AnthonyMouse on Wednesday January 19, 2022 @06:33PM (#30002026)
I'm fairly convinced that "wealth tax" is one of these things like "forgive student loans" that gets floated by people whose goal is to actually do nothing.

Because the idea is very bad, but it sounds good. So instead of the people who understand the dynamics and the people who want to make positive change working together to support something that would actually work, they spend all their time fighting each other. You spend years arguing and the best case is that you defeat the proposal for a bad idea that makes things worse, which is also the goal of the people distracting you away from doing something that would actually work.

Re:Millionaires group calls for wealth tax at virtual Davos by hotpotamus on Wednesday January 19, 2022 @06:46PM (#30002141)
Can you please tell the supposedly low tax state of Texas that these wealth taxes are a bad idea? I've got to pay mine to them in a few days.
Re:Millionaires group calls for wealth tax at virtual Davos by AnimalMuppet on Wednesday January 19, 2022 @07:20PM (#30002461)
I'm pretty sure you're trying to relabel property tax as a "wealth tax". Which it is in fact a tax on a subset of wealth. But it's not what all the rest of us are referring to when we say "wealth tax" in this thread. Your post therefore looks like a deliberate attempt at distraction.

To the best of my knowledge, Texas does not have a wealth tax in the sense that is under discussion.

Re:Millionaires group calls for wealth tax at virtual Davos by hotpotamus on Wednesday January 19, 2022 @07:28PM (#30002545)
I would say it's less a deliberate attempt at distraction and more of an impotent expression of annoyance at the discussion.
Re:Millionaires group calls for wealth tax at virtual Davos by imtringued on Thursday January 20, 2022 @07:07AM (#30007854)
Yeah and it would be much better if land value was taxed instead because that is effectively equivalent to paying for the share of society that you own, instead of taxing the wealth you created.

Right now the tax system is basically designed to make humans do as little work as possible. I don't mean that in a positive light. Employers don't want to hire people, they would rather hire machines because they are taxed less. Homeowners don't want to improve their home because they fear higher property taxes.

Re:Millionaires group calls for wealth tax at virtual Davos by AnthonyMouse on Wednesday January 19, 2022 @06:55PM (#30002251)
Texas has a wealth tax? When did this happen?
Re:Millionaires group calls for wealth tax at virtual Davos by dragonwriter on Wednesday January 19, 2022 @07:00PM (#30002306)
> Texas has a wealth tax?

Every US jurisdiction has at least one; it's called “property tax”, a wealth tax that has very broad exceptions (i.e., everything except real estate.) Texas has the 6th highest of the 50 states + DC.

Re:Millionaires group calls for wealth tax at virtual Davos by AnthonyMouse on Wednesday January 19, 2022 @07:16PM (#30002422)
Taxing land is kind of different because the owner didn't create it and it's not possible for anyone to cause more to exist. See discussion of Georgism etc.

Taxing buildings is a bad idea for the same kinds of reasons as a wealth tax is a bad idea, but an actual wealth tax doesn't have exceptions. Or if it does, that makes it even worse, because whatever the exceptions are will create a powerful arbitrage opportunity. Which, in the case of property tax, is one of the reasons we under-invest in housing construction and have high housing costs. (Restrictive zoning is an even larger factor, but might not be if property tax mill rates were higher.)

Re:Millionaires group calls for wealth tax at virtual Davos by dragonwriter on Wednesday January 19, 2022 @07:20PM (#30002471)
> Taxing land is kind of different because the owner didn't create it and it's not possible for anyone to cause more to exist.

Neither one of those things is categorically true of land (artificial land is a thing.)

> Taxing buildings is a bad idea for the same kinds of reasons as a wealth tax is a bad idea.

Whether or not it's a bad idea, it in fact exists, which was the question.

> but an actual wealth tax doesn't have exceptions

That's an unusual definition and doesn't seem like it matches any actual proposals that have been discussed with that name.

> Or if it does, that makes it even worse, because whatever the exceptions are will create a powerful arbitrage opportunity.

Why is this unconditionally a bad thing?

> Which, in the case of property tax, is one of the reasons we under-invest in housing construction and have high housing costs.

It’s really not, if it was, that problem would be inversely correlated with property tax rates, since those would determine the strength of that incentive.

Re:Millionaires group calls for wealth tax at virtual Davos by AnthonyMouse on Wednesday January 19, 2022 @07:46PM (#30002711)
> Neither one of those things is categorically true of land (artificial land is a thing.)

"Land" is the surface of the planet. You can make "artificial land" in the sense that you e.g. cover the ocean with something that passes for ground, but that's just a type of building. It doesn't change the size of the earth. The ocean has land under it that was there before you showed up.

> Whether or not it's a bad idea, it in fact exists, which was the question.

There is obviously a meaningful difference between a "property tax" and a "wealth tax" or else people would not be talking about instituting a wealth tax instead of just adjusting the rate (if desired) on the existing "wealth tax."

> Why is this unconditionally a bad thing?

Suppose you have a wealth tax that applies to everything except precious metals. Stock market immediately crashes to the level that risk adjusted returns match those of holding metals while not paying the wealth tax, and metal prices skyrocket.

Insert whatever you like as the exception, same thing happens. How is that not unconditionally a bad thing?

And you get something similar even if there are no formal exceptions, because there will be types of property which are harder to measure and wealth will pour into them with high inefficiency in order to avoid the tax.

> It’s really not, if it was, that problem would be inversely correlated with property tax rates, since those would determine the strength of that incentive.

Measuring this is confounded by several other strong forces, zoning being the main one, but also just differences between housing markets in different areas. So it's hard to measure above background noise with low absolute differences in property tax rates.

But what makes you think this doesn't happen? If rents are $2000/month and you can build a new unit of housing for a risk-adjusted net present cost equivalent to $1999/month, it's profitable to do so. If the new unit will have $100/month worth of property tax due, now the rent has to be $2100/month before it's profitable to do so, and less housing is constructed causing rents to remain higher. What would cause this not to be true?

Re:Millionaires group calls for wealth tax at virtual Davos by jakelazaroff on Wednesday January 19, 2022 @06:11PM (#30001827)
This is a little like saying that we just shouldn't have laws, because people will find ways to circumvent them.
Re:Millionaires group calls for wealth tax at virtual Davos by uejfiweun on Wednesday January 19, 2022 @06:19PM (#30001902)
If the target of a law can circumvent the law, and the law ends up harming regular middle and working class people, then yes we should not have this law.