Re:Are We Really Engineers? (2021)
by Scramblejams on Wednesday January 19, 2022 @05:47PM
(#30001528)
Intriguing! I'll have to let that percolate...
[ Parent
| on HN ]
I haven't fully figured out the implications to be honest. Some are more intuitive than others. For example, it would mean (some?) financial engineering is a misnomer ;) but it would also suggest that designing digital circuits is only engineering in certain cases, like high-speed cases where you have to make the design robust to extraneous analog effects. For what it's worth, I think it somewhat aligns somewhat with your point about abstractions.
Re:Are We Really Engineers? (2021)
by Scramblejams on Wednesday January 19, 2022 @07:18PM
(#30002449)
I appreciate the focus on abstractions. I'm unenthusiastic about giving up on (b), because when you've got a discipline where anybody can reach for any old terrible abstraction and stand some unholy monstrosity up that actually seems to work okay, I have a difficult time wanting to call it engineering.
And I am fully in favor of financial engineering not being engineering. :-)