Re:Are We Really Engineers? (2021)
by AlotOfReading on Wednesday January 19, 2022 @04:46PM
(#30000678)
Do you think engineers existed prior to the 18/19th century when degrees became a thing? It seems problematic to your definition that most of the wiki page on engineering is dedicated to things done by non-engineers.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Are We Really Engineers? (2021)
by a_wild_dandan on Wednesday January 19, 2022 @04:54PM
(#30000789)
Also there are people without any degrees that do far more engineering than many developers who hold software engineering degrees.
Re:Are We Really Engineers? (2021)
by kevin_thibedeau on Wednesday January 19, 2022 @05:12PM
(#30001053)
The engineering process is to apply design tools to architect a solution with expected performance before anything is built. In traditional engineering this generally boils down to mathematical models that dependably replicate expected behaviors to a known degree of error. Building happens after the modeling says a solution is possible.
With software, true engineering only happens if the development model can follow such a process. Nobody wants to put in the work to do this for all code though.
Re:Are We Really Engineers? (2021)
by closeparen on Wednesday January 19, 2022 @10:22PM
(#30004104)
Upfront-heavy design is a cost saving adaptation to the constraint that experimentation with large scale structures is expensive. Even then, traditional engineering disciplines are very much into prototypes, scale models, and intricate test and measurement apparatus.
Upfront design is one of the methodologies of engineering but so is trial and error.
Being a good engineer is adopting the right combination of methodologies to fit the problem space.
Being a good software engineer means knowing what you should plan out in advance and what you need to test and design as you go.
Itβs a simplistic definition. Since the topic of calling developers engineers is rather superfluous, I think we should go for simple definitions.
Re:Are We Really Engineers? (2021)
by kelseyfrog on Wednesday January 19, 2022 @05:43PM
(#30001493)
I can think of many simple yet incorrect definitions. They have as much utility as this one.