Even if some cloud service is not needed and it works with "only" a local app on your phone, the phones change quickly and even the OS. Even with backwards compatibility, ten years of lifetime already is ambitious. Devices used to have decades of lifetime. Electronics shortened it, computing elements more so, and now software. The cycles got shorter. The construction also got more and more flimsy. All the devices I got from my grandparents are still usable (cooking, mechanical calculator, photo, film), the more modern it is the less metal and the more cheap plastics that does not age well.
If we had an efficient recycling system, and renewable energy to power the entire cycle it would be doable albeit still wasteful. But we have neither. The cycle is mostly fueled with fossil fuels, adding more and more carbon from deep below ground, and containing the energy of the ancient sun, to the surface carbon cycle. It is not circular, the end products end up dumped somewhere.
It's actually intellectual property restrictions that make possible the kind of scam business model you described. And I think without them we would see the cost of living go down as major goods got cloned and extra costs were shaken out of the designs. 3D printers got 100x cheaper in ten years after the patents expired, and I think this principle can generalize.
Citation needed. Open source development proves that IP restrictions are not necessary to produce engineering development. And look at 3D printers. Their price went from $50k to $25k after the first ten years on the market, when they were under patent. When the patent expired, development exploded and ten years later the price had dropped to $250. One of the most popular 3D printers in the world, the Prusa i3, is completely open source. Certainly one cannot say that "without IP... everything grinds to a halt" when faced with these examples.
I’m not saying the economy can be run by volunteers. Engineers at Prusa are not volunteers, they get paid. And they make their designs all open source. They do not need intellectual property restrictions to make their product viable.
EDIT: Here is an interview with the creator of the first hobby 3D printer. In Europe, unlike the US, research projects are allowed to violate patents. He explicitly calls out the expiration of the patents as the thing that allowed them to expand beyond just research. https://www.3dsourced.com/interviews/reprap-dr-adrian-bowyer...
“We never had any problem with Stratasys complaining about what we were doing, there was only one thing that happened: we got a letter, very nice and very polite, very conciliatory, from one of their legal people saying they had a trademark on the term FDM and could we please not use it, so immediately I invented an equivalent term, which was FFF and we just edited everything on the site to that instead. That’s the only time they tried to interfere or anything else with the project. They never complained we were infringing upon their patent, which we weren’t of course [research projects in Europe can research a patented technology for the purpose of improving it without any kind of patent infringement], and we weren’t selling any machines.
“Once the patent expired in 2009, of course the project was free to do whatever it liked. Coincidentally, that was just a few months after we got the first printer working. It all came together fairly nicely in that regard.”
Just sayin'. It's not the Accountants, it's the Business majors hired by the investors that are the issue. At the end of the day, its the investment firms and the endless churn to increase profit year over year that does this.
- Company founded and makes quality product
- Company stagnates, doesn’t innovate, falls behind.
- New CEO can’t fix this, so turns “reliable” brand into “lowest cost brand” to preserve sales.
- Company goes bust anyways
Most companies that have a solid reputation can make more money selling at a higher price point and having bigger margins than the cheaper outsourced competitor.
I’ve been in a few companies like this - the aggressive cost cutting almost always happens after sales have started to tank. When sales are good, everyone is fat and happy and not looking to stir the pot.
Sure you have changes - you end up with a few major variations like top- and side-loaders and all that. But the old style doesn't fall off the face of the earth. And companies have plenty of time to simply watch and imitate.
Some people will select a washer based on the available color scheme or some “anti-bacterial” setting.
Or it can be as simple as “that washer is 20% cheaper, I don’t care if it doesn’t last as long”.
[1] - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eJ3RzGoQC4s [ video ]
They went from “major purchase that should last a decade” to “we’ll get a new one if this breaks”.
Company A makes a thing, maybe it was founded by the inventor of the thing, maybe not, but it makes a thing and it is PROUD to make the thing. The thing is reliable, durable, and it does what it is advertised to do, well. It's crafted with care, with QA and built with quality parts.
And THEN the beancounters come in. Oh-ho, they say, you can increase your profit margin on every unit sold if you replace this FooPart with a cheaply made mass produced overseas equivalent.
Also, we will reduce the number of expensive quality inspectors to save costs.
Actually, we are outsourcing ALL labor to overseas to save costs,
and etc etc, the cost of the unit probably doesn't decrease, but the profit margins sure look nice until the point confidence in the product collapses and sales tank.