For example - by offering a way for any provider to embed info boxes and search UIs, all competing with each other.
Or by reducing adverts to increase better quality organic results (Google can have much less cash and still run fine).
Or by solving all the basic search relevancy flaws discussed on Hacker News in recent weeks.
It’s true that Google can run in less money, but the argument can’t simply be that. Otherwise you’re effectively saying companies cannot make as much money as possible in general, no?
We don’t let chemical waste get poured into rivers.
Likewise, we shouldn’t allow harmful behaviour online. We have to as a society agree what that means, which is what is now finally happening.
Ultimately the businesses will still be viable, just different. Most likely more innovative and making better products in more competitive environments.
The question is whether or not better companies would be born and ultimately provide even greater services to the same set of customers.
That - is what is obviously harder to prove.
Personally I think the answer is to simply say that after a certain reach per industry a company must provide “access” to platforms or pay a percentage of revenue to nurture the smallest competitors.
—-
As an aside, I believe the bill in question (https://cdn.vox-cdn.com/uploads/chorus_asset/file/23177323/B...) is dumb.
Basically it bans ads as a model for monetization. Terrible idea imho.