News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A delightful quirk of relativity theory by vidarh on Tuesday January 18, 2022 @11:18AM (#29981390)
To me the main reason quantum effects does not affect the free will argument is because one can - and probably should given that otherwise it makes QM keep coming up -, reframe it to not worry about absolute determinism and instead apply just probabilistic models.

The real question becomes one of probabilities: Unless some entity is able to introduce measurable biases that deviates from predictable probabilistic distributions relative to what could be predicted based on its complete state (including its internal physical structure) and complete inputs, it makes little sense to suggest the entity has agency.

But that leaves us with the problem of explaining how something could effectively break the laws of physics in a way that doesn't just lead to infinite regress.

The day I see someone give a definition of free will that overcomes that, I'll be in awe. Not holding my breath.

Re:A delightful quirk of relativity theory by parineum on Tuesday January 18, 2022 @01:41PM (#29983730)
> Unless some entity is able to introduce measurable biases that deviates from predictable probabilistic distribution

This is always the problem with arguments for free will or at least the idea that one "could have done something different" that try to use physics/science.

It requires metaphysical action, literally something that cannot be understood with physics. The whole purpose of physics is to define the universe as deterministic. Quantum randomness is exactly that, random. If it was influenceable in some way, it wouldn't be random. Furthermore, the decision to influence it would still be deterministic so the metaphysics doesn't even make sense.

Quantum magic is just the bleeding edge of woo.