From the Wikipedia page on the thought experiment, check out Criticisms:
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rietdijk%E2%80%93Putnam_argu...
> The interpretations of relativity used in the Rietdijk–Putnam argument and the Andromeda paradox are not universally accepted.
> Howard Stein[5] and Steven F. Savitt[6] note that in relativity the present is a local concept that cannot be extended to global hyperplanes.
> Furthermore, N. David Mermin[7] states: That no inherent meaning can be assigned to the simultaneity of distant events is the single most important lesson to be learned from relativity. — David Mermin, It’s About Time
Rietdijk–Putnam argument, for example, appears to sort of elevate the idea of differing planes of simultaneity, taken from special relativity, to an idea of a four-dimensional universe. It’s a curious thought experiment and I wonder how it reconciles with a model where the universe is considered to be 4D with the fourth dimension being time. My intuition doesn’t work all that well beyond three dimension so I can’t tell if those are essentially the same or not.
It’s not falsifiable, but neither is string theory.
No. The only thing that is "happening right now" on Andromeda from my point of view is the causality wave (light) that is hitting me right now. It's nonsense to talk about anything happening "right now" if its causality wave hasn't reached me yet.
But even beyond that you have the math wrong. Andromeda galaxy is only 2.5 million light-years from Earth. To get a 1 day difference in time dilation across 2.5 million years would take 1 in 913 million difference which someone traveling at even 100MPH (45m/s) isn’t going to see. (1 - (45^2/((3x10^8)^2))^0.5 simply isn’t enough.
Chose a specific vector and both observers exactly agree with the events timing. Essentially the only thing they disagree about is what Andromeda’s location and velocity is. (Edited this several times, but it all simplified to choice of vectors.)
But even that’s assuming spaceships rather than “one stationary and one travelling past in a car” the guy in a car is never going to end up light years distant from the stationary person.