Re:A delightful quirk of relativity theory
by vidarh on Tuesday January 18, 2022 @08:11AM
(#29978481)
"Rescuing free-will" would depend on there being something to rescue in the first place. I've yet to see a definition of free will that a casual observer would agree is "free" once you strip it of the smoke and mirrors.
To me the Andromeda Paradox isn't very interesting, because the question is only problematic if you consider time as a process that events happen within simultaneously in a way that you can precisely globally order by positing some way of counting objective units of time backwards from the point the two people on earth both see the invasion force.
If you instead look at the passage of time as simply the propagation of cause and effect where the propagation rate may differ depending on features of the events being propagated, then you get a dependency graph where when you interact different cause-effect chains meet. Only the nodes (events happening) matters, not the edges (the unobservable-because-nothing-interacted other than propagation).
The notion of something happening simultaneously then becomes abstract - you have no objective matter of measuring something being simultaneous except by whether or not they directly interact in a given moment. You're relying on your universe behaving in a way that means you can count events to try to maintain a chronology on the basis you know how they're spaced apart. But the best we can do is count the number of such events that happens in different frames under different conditions between causal chains merging.
Once you ditch the idea of "global ordering time" the "paradox" is nothing of the sort.
Because in that respect talking about "when" the event in Andromeda happened is meaningless, because it is a conversation based on projecting a model of the world as it appears from one local part of that cause-effect graph to another on the basis that there's an objective global ordering outside of what we can impose by counting chronology comparing clock time when we directly interact. It may make your mental model of what happened when messy, but that is because thinking of what happened when instead of what interacted with what in which order is messy.
(if there's any way of achieving faster than light travel, my totally-usupported-by-any-theory bet is that it would show our notion of time to be too static, and that it'd "bypass" the cause-and-effect paradoxes by affecting the laws of physics at the points of FTL interactions)
To me the Andromeda Paradox isn't very interesting, because the question is only problematic if you consider time as a process that events happen within simultaneously in a way that you can precisely globally order by positing some way of counting objective units of time backwards from the point the two people on earth both see the invasion force.
If you instead look at the passage of time as simply the propagation of cause and effect where the propagation rate may differ depending on features of the events being propagated, then you get a dependency graph where when you interact different cause-effect chains meet. Only the nodes (events happening) matters, not the edges (the unobservable-because-nothing-interacted other than propagation).
The notion of something happening simultaneously then becomes abstract - you have no objective matter of measuring something being simultaneous except by whether or not they directly interact in a given moment. You're relying on your universe behaving in a way that means you can count events to try to maintain a chronology on the basis you know how they're spaced apart. But the best we can do is count the number of such events that happens in different frames under different conditions between causal chains merging.
Once you ditch the idea of "global ordering time" the "paradox" is nothing of the sort.
Because in that respect talking about "when" the event in Andromeda happened is meaningless, because it is a conversation based on projecting a model of the world as it appears from one local part of that cause-effect graph to another on the basis that there's an objective global ordering outside of what we can impose by counting chronology comparing clock time when we directly interact. It may make your mental model of what happened when messy, but that is because thinking of what happened when instead of what interacted with what in which order is messy.
(if there's any way of achieving faster than light travel, my totally-usupported-by-any-theory bet is that it would show our notion of time to be too static, and that it'd "bypass" the cause-and-effect paradoxes by affecting the laws of physics at the points of FTL interactions)