News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:US claims jurisdiction over all .com/.net sites even if o... by drubio on Monday January 17, 2022 @08:12PM (#29973673)
In more recent news, this tech https://handshake.org/ is aimed at this kind of jurisdictional issue. Limiting the reach of a US court or any other central org for that matter at shutting down a domain .com, .net or other.
Re:US claims jurisdiction over all .com/.net sites even if o... by jedberg on Monday January 17, 2022 @08:49PM (#29973968)
The only way an alternate TLD registrar will ever take off is if you get the people who own the current root servers on board. And the only way that will happen is if you figure out how they can make money from owning and operating the root servers.

My guess is that if you create a blockchain for registering DNS, and only the current registrars can issue coins on said blockchain, you might have a solution they would be willing to implement. You'd still have to pay them money to register a new domain or maintain it, but once you had the coin, you could register whatever you wanted and no government could stop you.

Re:US claims jurisdiction over all .com/.net sites even if o... by drubio on Monday January 17, 2022 @09:11PM (#29974138)
And more importantly than letting you register, it avoids a .com, .net domain getting one of these on a landing page https://www.justice.gov/sites/default/files/styles/width_12/...

This has been the story for many sites, where domains are seized even if owned by a non-US person/company, with an order to the TLD that operates in the US. With a distributed DNS system like Handshake, 'in theory' this shouldn't be possible, since it would require multiple nodes to alter a domain's DNS records vs. a central TLD authority which has to abide by US law.

It's all interesting, but it still seems we are ways off from the DNS backbone (& my browser) operating with this kind of DNS architecture. It even appears it's becoming easier to take down a domain, not at the TLD/registrar level, but more so at the hosting level (e.g. Parler)

Re:US claims jurisdiction over all .com/.net sites even if o... by legutierr on Monday January 17, 2022 @09:17PM (#29974179)
Is it the root servers that you need to get on board, or the publishers of the publications that most people use, or the operating system publishers?

For instance, if the browser makers all started resolving certain TLDs via an alternate network, then people could start publishing websites using domains managed by that network without needing to engage with the root DNS servers at all.

Re:US claims jurisdiction over all .com/.net sites even if o... by jedberg on Monday January 17, 2022 @09:20PM (#29974204)
It would be a start, but not all of the internet is accessed through a browser. And I'm not sure you'd get Apple and Google on board unless there was a way for them to make money from it.
Re:US claims jurisdiction over all .com/.net sites even if o... by rasengan on Monday January 17, 2022 @09:08PM (#29974119)
Those servers are only necessary for the ICANN tlds and those will continue to act as they do today, even in a Handshake future.

With Handshake, you run your own authoritative server (or use a hosted one) for your own name and that authoritative server's information will be obtainable on chain. No middle-man, no rent seeking.

Re:US claims jurisdiction over all .com/.net sites even if o... by jedberg on Monday January 17, 2022 @09:15PM (#29974166)
I understand how handshake works. What I'm saying is that getting my mom to point her DNS servers at an alternate server is a non-starter. You have to get the root servers on board to carry all TLDs or most people will never find them.
Re:US claims jurisdiction over all .com/.net sites even if o... by DarylZero on Monday January 17, 2022 @09:19PM (#29974196)
But then the root servers can still be used to censor domains by removing them.
Re:US claims jurisdiction over all .com/.net sites even if o... by jedberg on Monday January 17, 2022 @09:22PM (#29974220)
They aren't all in the US. Right now they remove a .com by telling Verisign, a US company, to change the registration for the .com. Since Verisign is the only way to change a .com, it works.

Many root servers operate outside of the US. If the blockchain were the authority on IP addresses, then even if they blocked the US roots the others would still have it.

Even today if all the US root servers go off-line every system would find the others and use them.

Re:US claims jurisdiction over all .com/.net sites even if o... by DarylZero on Tuesday January 18, 2022 @10:03AM (#29980169)
> If the blockchain were the authority on IP addresses

But it's not -- the root servers are -- by premise here. Premise is we assume zero config results in ICANN root servers having authority. My point is that given this premise, blockchain is ineffective. You are introducing ICANN as informational MITM and censor node in between user and blockchain validation.

True, you are excluding USA, if your only goal is exclude USA then this accomplishes that goal, but if your goal is censorship-proof then this is not it.

Re:US claims jurisdiction over all .com/.net sites even if o... by sneak on Monday January 17, 2022 @09:28PM (#29974270)
Browser extensions and apps can start resolving alternate roots using non-DNS methods for those who opt-in.
Re:US claims jurisdiction over all .com/.net sites even if o... by jedberg on Monday January 17, 2022 @09:33PM (#29974303)
Sure, but again, that will never take off. "Install this plugin to access our website" is a non-starter for most people.
Re:US claims jurisdiction over all .com/.net sites even if o... by rasengan on Monday January 17, 2022 @09:38PM (#29974346)
It doesn't seem different from "install this app" to access our services though? And clearly, this model has proliferated with fluidity.
Re:US claims jurisdiction over all .com/.net sites even if o... by jedberg on Monday January 17, 2022 @09:51PM (#29974432)
Installing apps is easy, built into the phone. And comes from a curated store run by a US company.

Installing plugins is well beyond the capabilities of most people, especially since the plugins for the default browsers come from a curated store run by US companies.

Re:US claims jurisdiction over all .com/.net sites even if o... by salawat on Monday January 17, 2022 @10:16PM (#29974609)
...Only because we (software engineers, developers, etc...) have completely failed in managing to make our field more communicable to users, and have gone down the path of complicating the hell out of things instead of nailing down the primitives and onboarding to the field.

I'm not even talking any wishy washy inclusiveness mumbo jumbo either. I'm talking over complicating the boot chain, over complicating memory management/models/toolchains.

Browsers are a living nightmare of complexity, and I am continuously amazed at the number of programmers who have no clue about the gory details of networking.

Re:US claims jurisdiction over all .com/.net sites even if o... by blooalien on Tuesday January 18, 2022 @03:03PM (#29984912)
> … "and have gone down the path of complicating the hell out of things instead of nailing down the primitives and onboarding to the field."

I've thought much this same thing myself for ages now.

Not just "complicating the hell out of things" either. Complicating the hell out of things that should be simple ( or at least should be simplified, or automated, or something ). I see a lot of tedious activities in modern computing that appear to exist purely for the sake of the tedium time-wastery factor.

The flip-side of the same coin is the over-simplifying or "dumbing down" of some things that really should stay "complicated" (and hidden behind an "expert mode" toggle) to the point of allowing willfully uneducated morons to repeatedly "shoot themselves in the foot" and justify blaming everyone and everything but themselves for their error.

That sort of "computers should be an appliance like a toaster" mentality has contributed to a culture which seems convinced they should be able to magically jump from zero to "Hacker-Man" with no effort or learning required, the very same day they decide to "learn" programming.

Re:US claims jurisdiction over all .com/.net sites even if o... by DarylZero on Tuesday January 18, 2022 @10:22AM (#29980473)
Products created for the purpose of lock-in can't invite user participation because the first thing user-participants would do is remediate lock-in.
Re:US claims jurisdiction over all .com/.net sites even if o... by easrng on Monday January 17, 2022 @08:32PM (#29973828)
Handshake is awful. Because they decided to allow anyone to register a TLD there's no way to determine if a name needs to be resolved with handshake other than trying to resolve it.
Re:US claims jurisdiction over all .com/.net sites even if o... by Ajedi32 on Monday January 17, 2022 @10:30PM (#29974709)
Yeah, IMO they should have gone the Tor route and registered `.hs` or something with ICANN and then made all Handshake domains a subdomain of that. That'd have made it way easier for software to support Handshake without breaking compatibility with traditional DNS roots.
Re:US claims jurisdiction over all .com/.net sites even if o... by drubio on Monday January 17, 2022 @08:48PM (#29973960)
Interesting, I had no idea they were letting anyone register data, I had initially thought the idea was for registrars to provide nodes & data to eventually phase out the current DNS architecture, ensuring no single TLD org could wipe out a domain.

The Handshake design still seems like a step in the right direction, but even with sound data, it's probably years away (if ever) for DNS resolution to "flip the switch" to use this kind of architecture.

Re:US claims jurisdiction over all .com/.net sites even if o... by rasengan on Monday January 17, 2022 @08:38PM (#29973882)
There was a time when some used /etc/hosts whilst others used DNS. It was definitely a different time. Resolution issues with Handshake TLDs will easily be solved in time.

There are, however, other reasons why one might think Handshake isn't up to par just yet. Those reasons might be, for example, even though it completes the internet, making it significantly more secure and sovereign, the current implementations including DANE aren't as fast. Of course, this too [1] will be addressed with time.

There are highly technical people working on these problems with a heavy lean on making sure the experience is comparable if not better than today's expected experience. I think things will only get better from here.

[1] https://github.com/handshake-org/HIPs/discussions/44

Re:US claims jurisdiction over all .com/.net sites even if o... by salawat on Monday January 17, 2022 @10:28PM (#29974690)
See, this is an interesting problem.

Seems like you might be caught on the infinite abstraction escalator though, as who will manage the DNSNS (Domain Name Service NameSpaces) servers, and who'll take the onus for making the standard selector or display for the user to decide which lookup to consider canon for the request? This would actually be a pretty exciting development.

This would greatly complicate domain squatting (or maybe intensify/arms race it), and add a layer of resilience in the form of building up the interfaces required for users to maintain their own private DNS namespaces. This would conclusively shut the door in terms of centralized seizability of domains, since the user would in effect be empowered to be their own registrar.

You could even keep the traditional stuff seizable I guess. However, you'd be able to ask the fellow down the street if he still had the old DNS entry for x.y.z

Re:US claims jurisdiction over all .com/.net sites even if o... by walrus01 on Monday January 17, 2022 @08:39PM (#29973888)
yet another alternate root DNS that has maybe 0.001% of install base on the global scale of client devices with browsers?

yeah okay

seen it for 20 years now...

Re:US claims jurisdiction over all .com/.net sites even if o... by jiveturkey on Monday January 17, 2022 @09:04PM (#29974095)
wow, that's generous. more like 1x10-12, if that

.001% would be absolutely enormous, and the actual start of a thing.

the design and use case of it looks laughable to me. however, it does spark the imagination.

Re:US claims jurisdiction over all .com/.net sites even if o... by walrus01 on Tuesday January 18, 2022 @01:15AM (#29975744)
yeah that was overly charitable, reality would be more like 0.00000001% of client devices. considering we now have several billion internet using cellphones and people globally.
Re:US claims jurisdiction over all .com/.net sites even if o... by DarylZero on Tuesday January 18, 2022 @10:46AM (#29980853)
Not that it's going to do any better but more relevant figure is the percentage of routers... those client devices just accept configuration from the upstream network.
Re:US claims jurisdiction over all .com/.net sites even if o... by democracy on Monday January 17, 2022 @09:23PM (#29974226)
>> github developers with over 15 followers on February 2019

...I am wondering if it must also be a javascript project...

Re:US claims jurisdiction over all .com/.net sites even if o... by dmitryminkovsky on Monday January 17, 2022 @08:58PM (#29974034)
Thank you for sharing.

> even gnutella became The Pirate Bay.

Never thought about that.

[dead]
[dead]
Re:US claims jurisdiction over all .com/.net sites even if o... by CameronNemo on Monday January 17, 2022 @09:49PM (#29974416)
I mean Andrew Lee did drive away all of the communities that were on freenode.
Re:US claims jurisdiction over all .com/.net sites even if o... by rasengan on Monday January 17, 2022 @09:57PM (#29974474)
Depends on if you look at it based on a narrative that the former-staff wanted people to hear, or if you base it on the truth [1][2]. Specifically, this person states that I was in a position to "abuse my power" at freenode, such would mean that the statements he and others made in the past saying I had nothing to do with freenode until I "came in with lawyers" untrue, no? It's probably not worth spending cycles to research, but I'll leave these links if you're interested.

That said, a person simply can't defeat the cryptographically secured names of Handshake, so even if I was the boogie man, unless I have found the One Piece of Quantum CPU and harnessed its chakra[3], I'd be hard-pressed in fulfilling the boogie man role. ;)

[1] https://old.freenode.net/static/files/on-freenode.pdf

[2] https://news.itsfoss.com/freenode-controversy/

[3] intentionally put chakra and not haki here to make that more playful.

Re:US claims jurisdiction over all .com/.net sites even if o... by khm on Monday January 17, 2022 @10:49PM (#29974854)
I look at it from the narrative that I ran a decades-old channel on Freenode, and your scripts deopped me, removed my control of the channel, and opped some rando who had never even been there before. I have no stake in any of the other posturing from either side: I had a channel with a couple hundred users, and then I did not. We had no choice but to move to another ircnet (not one operated by people dumb enough to get their network snatched from under them, either).

Handshake is yet another cryptocoin grift entirely reliant on the assumption that it will never be important enough to attack. Its anti-government-control claims are equivalent to a high-school student in Tulsa bragging that Mike Tyson is afraid to fight him -- it's not that anyone is convinced Handshake is unassailable, it's just that nobody cares.

Re:US claims jurisdiction over all .com/.net sites even if o... by rasengan on Monday January 17, 2022 @10:58PM (#29974910)
That's unfortunate about your channel - I really do wish the former staff didn't stage a hostile take over and begin their attack on freenode. It's really unfortunate, and I'm sorry for that.

As for your comment on Handshake, you sound a lot like the opponents we used to face in the early days of crypto and the cypherpunk movement. That means we're getting somewhere! :-)

Re:US claims jurisdiction over all .com/.net sites even if o... by anonymoushn on Monday January 17, 2022 @11:20PM (#29975065)
You did that to his channel tho lmao
Re:US claims jurisdiction over all .com/.net sites even if o... by rasengan on Monday January 17, 2022 @11:24PM (#29975092)
> I was klined for saying "ensenga" so I wasn't around to see what really happened

> You did that to his channel tho lmao

Sigh.

Re:US claims jurisdiction over all .com/.net sites even if o... by anonymoushn on Monday January 17, 2022 @11:18PM (#29975050)
I was klined for saying "ensenga" so I wasn't around to see what really happened
Re:US claims jurisdiction over all .com/.net sites even if o... by judge2020 on Monday January 17, 2022 @10:30PM (#29974704)
I imagine less people left because of the "cries" and more because of the _actual_ hostile channel takeovers?[0][1]

Not even mentioning the blocking of IRCCloud users [2] and not handling GDPR requests, despite servers and users in the EU [3].

0: https://www.devever.net/~hl/freenode_abuse

1: https://redd.it/nyp855

2: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27495358

3: https://twitter.com/mjg59/status/1407790283308240897/photo/1

Re:US claims jurisdiction over all .com/.net sites even if o... by rasengan on Monday January 17, 2022 @10:37PM (#29974761)
Again, the narrative one wishes to hear, but, to be clear:

[0] No different from Microsoft taking control of a repository that many relied upon.

[1] There was an active spam attack going on. [x1]

[2] IRC cloud deceptively labeled freenode a malicious network. Seemed fair to ban them since they were collecting rent from users that were using the network. Probably better than a libel lawsuit that we were recommended to file.

[3] freenode isn't subject to GDPR. Jurisdiction is an interesting topic given the scope of this thread by the way!

To be clear, I don't appreciate the perpetuation of the false narrative -- once it started to become death threats, the safety of my family elevated this to a much higher level of concern and obviously things are being investigated. As has been the same position of mine from the beginning, I continue to protect freenode and have always seeked [x2] to give ownership and control of it to the community [x3].

[x1] https://gist.github.com/realrasengan/88549ec34ee32d01629354e...

[x2] https://old.freenode.net/static/files/on-freenode.pdf

[x3] https://freenode.net/n/freenode/80/freenode-belongs-to-you

Re:US claims jurisdiction over all .com/.net sites even if o... by judge2020 on Monday January 17, 2022 @10:46PM (#29974843)
As I said, these are reasons that people left, not a telling of a specific narrative on whether or not you did things correctly.

As for GDPR, Jurisdiction is indeed an interesting topic, one that is less defined by laws and more gunboat diplomacy[0] - the US and EU understand this, but perhaps not Freenode Limited.

0: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gunboat_diplomacy

Re:US claims jurisdiction over all .com/.net sites even if o... by rasengan on Monday January 17, 2022 @10:52PM (#29974881)
I think attorneys who specialize in this know better than you?

Sorry for the delay in response as well, you kept changing this comment to try to sway the narrative a certain way, so I had to wait until you finished your edits to make sure my reply would make sense.

Edit: In the spirit of editing comments, any continuance of this which is completely off topic is malicious at best. Best of luck to you.