Re:The writer who made me love comics taught me to hate them...
by crooked-v on Tuesday January 18, 2022 @02:35AM
(#29976214)
Worm has the basic issue that most of the answers to those questions don't actually make much sense, and end up justified outside the page by the presence of a secret conspiracy that's arranged everything to work that way with a set of uniquely powerful super-abilities.
(They tried and failed, but at least they tried.)
It's possible to tell superhero comics that don't fall into the traps, but I don't think it can be done directly in the medium of continuing comics: without a planned conclusion, it becomes self-negating or self-parodying.
A different critique is offered by Wildbow's _Worm_, a giant webnovel that tried to provide consistent reasons for all the superhero comic tropes: why do mass-murdering villains get to live? Why do they escape from custody so regularly? How do they store their money? What's most important, thinking or action? The novel is 1.7 million words long, and has generated about 250 million words of fanfic...