News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:€2.6M spent for a book at auction, believed they would ow... by Waterluvian on Monday January 17, 2022 @07:39AM (#29965934)
So many conversations here and on Twitter focus on laughing at these people.

But I think the most likely explanation is that they’re not this stupid. That it’s some form of fraud.

Re:€2.6M spent for a book at auction, believed they would ow... by f6v on Monday January 17, 2022 @09:59AM (#29967160)
I’ve been reading some crypto- and NFT focused Telegram channels. There’re many people who’d willingly “invest” into something like this.
Re:€2.6M spent for a book at auction, believed they would ow... by cfj on Monday January 17, 2022 @10:10AM (#29967284)
Are you familiar with Hanlon's razor?
Re:€2.6M spent for a book at auction, believed they would ow... by Waterluvian on Monday January 17, 2022 @10:18AM (#29967371)
Sure. And Occam's razor. These are nice one-liners but not rules to base perspectives on.

What I'm focusing on is how everyone loves to feel smart, and most do that by making others feel dumb. And when you are anti-something (yes, I am anti NFT), you have further motivation to just chalk it up to, "haha look at these bozos."

The more useful, and in my opinion, more likely hypothesis to spend all our oxygen on is, "what kind of fraud might be going on here?" For example, did someone just make a ton of money by convincing a bunch of chumps to fund this?

Re:€2.6M spent for a book at auction, believed they would ow... by bidder33 on Monday January 17, 2022 @11:40AM (#29968374)
Or maybe it is simply a group of people who love jodos vision for dune. the idea of a film as a guiding prophet, visions of a flowing creative universe. and we want to play with that.

so we raised a bunch of funds and bought a cool book. now we are making an animation. we've been discussing ideas like sending funds to the makers of Jodorowskys Dune documentary which didnt even break even, as a way of thanking them too.

y'know, playing in the way we were taught, as hackers, as kids who grew up on the internet. To go out and do things, make things. hang out with our friends.

but hn would rather take a few snippets, call us all scammers and frauds, and hate on us.

but whatever.. we're gonna keep having fun ¯\_ (ツ)_/¯

Re:€2.6M spent for a book at auction, believed they would ow... by monkey_monkey on Monday January 17, 2022 @01:01PM (#29969408)
> so we raised a bunch of funds and bought a cool book.

For about 100x its estimated value. I'm not sure that's really playing with a hacker mentality.

The plan is also to burn the "cool book". Again, I'm unsure how that fits into a hacker mindset.

Re:€2.6M spent for a book at auction, believed they would ow... by bidder33 on Monday January 17, 2022 @02:57PM (#29971044)
I think playing with money systems, ideas of value etc is interesting. The average contribution was about $50 - so like a kickstarter for a fan club.

and no, the plan is not to burn the book. there is an ongoing joke by a few people in the dao. but they do not represent the majority and the aims of the dao explicitly are to do with the preservation and protection of the book. so thats not going to happen.

but people arent actually interested in conversation here. hn hates crypto. we get it. people hating something they arent a part of and dont understand. But we are still going to have fun and make things, and the good vibes win in the end.

Re:€2.6M spent for a book at auction, believed they would ow... by monkey_monkey on Monday January 17, 2022 @03:39PM (#29971462)
Sure, I guess overpaying by 2 orders of magnitude is playing with money systems.

Do enjoy your exploration into copyright and IP law.