From a purely technical standpoint, I agree (and wouldn't put it past Intel either). My argument is that having an open ISA makes it easier for manufacturers to compete with each other, which in turn makes it harder for interested parties to pin down every CPU manufacturer and punch holes in their individual designs.
> Sure you're open to buy RISC-V CPUs from China but how are you going to be certain that they have no backdoors?
Pragmatically, you can't. My point though was more that open ISAs give us options to buy hardware that doesn't get designed domestically, which is the main enabler for companies like AMD, Intel and Apple, and moreover, the government. If one chip is confirmed to be vulnerable in some way, you'll have legitimate competitors to choose from.
There seems to be a bit of a consistent thread running through lots of discussions that RISC-V because its 'open' magically solves all sorts of problems - it does have some advantages - but it doesn't solve these issues any more than Arm does (and Arm already has massive diversity of supply and billions of CPUs shipped without ME type issues).
Sure you're open to buy RISC-V CPUs from China but how are you going to be certain that they have no backdoors?