News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Lenovo vendor locking Ryzen CPUs with AMD PSB by fartcannon on Sunday January 16, 2022 @03:14PM (#29959502)
The hypothetical homogeneous group 'they' you refer to doesn't exist. It's billions of people and 'they' feel many ways. By painting with a common brush, you shut down discussions of what could be and encourage fence sitters to give up. Let's talk about why it's possible, easy to do, and how to do it.

The more fence sitters you convince that things are possible, pushes the fence further and further towards the other side.

Re:Lenovo vendor locking Ryzen CPUs with AMD PSB by kube-system on Sunday January 16, 2022 @03:23PM (#29959587)
I disagree. Market targeting, segmentation, and consumer preferences are real things which can be and are routinely measured.
Re:Lenovo vendor locking Ryzen CPUs with AMD PSB by jkepler on Sunday January 16, 2022 @04:26PM (#29960265)
Exactly the parent commercial it's point: market segments /can/ and do change sizes and their proportional relations. And more people are beginning to understand the importance of security for privacy in a world that is increasingly digital and dependent on information technology.
Re:Lenovo vendor locking Ryzen CPUs with AMD PSB by kube-system on Monday January 17, 2022 @01:13PM (#29969596)
Yes, several of these companies have come out of nowhere in the past decade and are now making low single digit millions in revenue. Huge growth, yes, but also, still a rounding error as far as the whole market is concerned.
Re:Lenovo vendor locking Ryzen CPUs with AMD PSB by jacquesm on Sunday January 16, 2022 @03:27PM (#29959619)
That's agreement, not disagreement.
Re:Lenovo vendor locking Ryzen CPUs with AMD PSB by kube-system on Sunday January 16, 2022 @03:46PM (#29959816)
I am saying that the market for people who care about these types of things is objectively niche. Large manufacturers build what they build because they fund the research to know what to build. And they are successful at selling them because they were correct.

There might be billions of people buying computers, but the set that has any opinion on boot code signing requirements is not large enough to cause any significant impact on the market as a whole.

There are companies that cater to these niche markets, like Pine/Framework/System76/Purism. They are tiny. Dell sells more computers in a single contract than all of these other companies have sold over their entire existence combined.

Re:Lenovo vendor locking Ryzen CPUs with AMD PSB by jkepler on Sunday January 16, 2022 @05:16PM (#29960829)
True. However, sometimes large buyers, such as governments or enterprises, change their policies towards purchasing requirements. For example, since 2013 France has had an Inter-Ministry Foundation of Free Software[0], which provides the preferred software to be used across France's government, as French law requires preference be given to free software (logiciel libre).

What impact might occur if a government like France were to require in the future only RISC V architectures with free boot loaders, of if the US government or a large corporation required use of measured boot to see at boot-time if the boot code or subsequent OS had been compromised?

With persistent threat actors and the falling price of processing power, I wouldn't be surprised if in the next ten years some larger organizations (or tens of thousands of small businesses) start demanding this kind if IT security from their vendors.

[0] (in French, of course) https://sill.etalab.gouv.fr/fr/software and their repo, https://github.com/disic/sill.

Re:Lenovo vendor locking Ryzen CPUs with AMD PSB by BoorishBears on Sunday January 16, 2022 @03:48PM (#29959840)
This is very feel good but falls short of making an actual point.

> The hypothetical homogeneous group 'they' you refer to doesn't exist

They do exist. Making wrong statements with conviction doesn't make it true.

You can look Chromebook sales figures, you can look at the best selling laptops at major retailers, you can look at what's driving record laptop sales, look at price points that are soaring, look at the mobile space...

-

> It's billions of people and 'they' feel many ways.

Which is why we draw conclusions based on a large sample size like I did above. You're never going to be able to consider billions of points of view, so yes, you need to try and find the common thread in their preferences and usages.

-

> By painting with a common brush, you shut down discussions of what could be and encourage fence sitters to give up.

No, by painting with a common brush, you can have actual useful discussions about the reality of things, rather than espousing your own personal whims.

-

> Let's talk about why it's possible, easy to do, and how to do it.

a) Where did my comment say it's impossible?

b) It's not easy to do or it wouldn't have existed in the first place. The whole point of my comment is saying that you need to figure out how to do it taking the current reality of things into context.

If the world thought how HN does we'd already have bills banning IME and PSB. So it doesn't. You can't pretend that people actually are a little nudge away from caring about this, or you'll quickly find that you're wrong and nothing will have actually changed.

-

> The more fence sitters you convince that things are possible, pushes the fence further and further towards the other side.

Again, what you could do if you believed that fence sitters were some large portion of laptop buyers is do what I've done, show some indications of this. Show us how niche efforts aimed at power users aren't the only rumblings about how awful locked down computing is.

What you're doing is still painting a group with a large brush, except you're not even showing us where you got the paint.

Re:Lenovo vendor locking Ryzen CPUs with AMD PSB by fartcannon on Sunday January 16, 2022 @04:50PM (#29960533)
Huh? I like your ideas, but I'm not painting. I'm saying "don't paint". If you think of it like a nice dividing line through the people who think stuff can change and the people who don't, the folks on the line are 'on the fence'. You see? If you can convince a few of them (not large swathes of them, just a few), then the line shifts. If we all do that, we can change a lot of minds for good!

You get what I mean? So yeah, my recommendation is that we all talk like things are easy to make better, instead of saying, "too late its all over" because you'll encourage more people to try which I assume you agree is a good thing but if not, I guess to each their own.

Re:Lenovo vendor locking Ryzen CPUs with AMD PSB by BoorishBears on Sunday January 16, 2022 @07:01PM (#29961792)
I'm saying you're painting though, and I'm saying you can't talk like things are easy to get better and have a meaningful conversation.

Instead of trying to act like most people will ever care about locked bootloaders and PSB style co-processors, why don't we accept that they don't, they won't, and see what can happen from there?

An example of that is looking at it from a national security perspective. If you can paint it as a vulnerability to the tech industry you could see movement without the sisyphean task of convincing people that this stuff matters in their day-to-day lives

Re:Lenovo vendor locking Ryzen CPUs with AMD PSB by fartcannon on Sunday January 16, 2022 @07:19PM (#29961915)
Interesting! I have to disagree that it can't lead to a meaningful conversation, but I'm definitely on board with painting it as a tech vulnerability!