My comment, agree or not, stated precisely why his logic was flawed.
Further, appealing to authority is a logical fallacy. The facts count.
"pretty qualified thinkers" are putting out all sorts of thought provoking ideas with no intention of being right all the time.
Sure, perhaps I was inarticulate - he’s a world leading medical researcher who heads up a world leading medical research institution; he is one of the 10 most cited medical researchers in the world. Yadda yadda…
(Edited - asimpletune above said it more eloquently than I did!)