> We don't have Barons and Lords because they got obliterated by unified nation states in wars, every time.
Arguably the most militarily successful empire in history [0] has Barons and Lords and is nearly contemporary with this conversation (Elizabeth II isn't even dead yet). I agree democracy is better, but "we're better organised and we'll whack you if you don't pay protection money" is a weak justification for taxes. The counterargument is that bullying is a decent tactic but a bad strategy - it is hard to get people to seriously buy in to bullying and relatively unstable when the situation changes.
Re:Why Galesburg has no money
by ClumsyPilot on Sunday January 16, 2022 @09:16PM
(#29962653)
I don't think British Empire is considered feudal society, the English civil war probably marks the end of anything you could call feudalism.
The argument is diffetent - feudalism gives you multiple warring rackets, its even worse and more expensive
We already ran this experiment, it was called Feudalism. We don't have Barons and Lords because they got obliterated by unified nation states in wars, every time.
There are people who'd give their life for America/Freedom/ etc, have you ever met anyone who would for Mark Zukerberg?
Under current system police enjoys mahor privilidges - qualified immunity, resisting arrest is a crime, etc. Since such multiple private army/police's might come into conflict, those privilidges have to go. We'll be back at feudal warfare