News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Hellofresh employees' open salary initiative by pc86 on Saturday January 15, 2022 @11:55AM (#29947934)
The root cause is an open argument but I think one of the causes is that you get a demonstrably lower quality of employee because the pay can't be negotiated, and it's pegged so far below market it's insulting. The salary you mentioned is half that of the median developer salary in the US. If you can get into FAANG as a new grad you're looking at 1.5-2x the median. I'm not super familiar with UW's scaling system but I have to go to what appears to be the top level (ES10?) to get anything approaching a reasonable salary, and it's still less than entry level FAANG.

I used to contract for state government. They used contractors for all the "real development" because the developers on state payroll making $40k/yr were wholly unqualified to write any code. So they paid a contracting firm $80/hr to get someone making $100k/yr to come in and do it while the state employees managed the project and supervised the contractors.

If the government could just negotiate individual salaries for developers, they could pay them twice as much, fire the contractors, and get the work done for roughly the same quality, and cheaper.

Re:Hellofresh employees' open salary initiative by spenczar5 on Saturday January 15, 2022 @12:11PM (#29948090)
So, my previous role was as a PE in AWS. I made a high multiple of my current salary, yes.

I think the quality of people around me at UW is mostly just different. Domain expertise is much deeper - the image processing experts really know their stuff! While fundamental systems and devops stuff is pretty absent from anyone’s skillsets. I don’t think you can really simply say that the talent quality is better or worse - it’s different.

I work at UW because I prefer the content of the work over my past at AWS. It turns out there are lots of people like me, who agree that $120k is plenty, and who made a very cushy pile of cash in the past at FAANG.

Re:Hellofresh employees' open salary initiative by jonas21 on Saturday January 15, 2022 @02:32PM (#29949402)
The number listed for you on the website is $57,800, and I assume that's what the parent was basing their comment on.
Re:Hellofresh employees' open salary initiative by spenczar5 on Saturday January 15, 2022 @02:35PM (#29949434)
Ah, that is confusing since it is for a fraction of the year. I am paid $120k/yr, which is typical.
Re:Hellofresh employees' open salary initiative by mentat on Saturday January 15, 2022 @01:02PM (#29948635)
It's plenty for people who already have a pile of cash. That seems a bit problematic right?
Re:Hellofresh employees' open salary initiative by xref on Saturday January 15, 2022 @01:11PM (#29948709)
Depends on your lifestyle but for the bulk of Americans $120k is extremely cushy, at nearly 4x the median salary of $35k
Re:Hellofresh employees' open salary initiative by HideousKojima on Saturday January 15, 2022 @02:45PM (#29949526)
It apso puts you in the ~75th percentile for household income in the US, if your spouse also works you're doing far better than the vast majority of Americans.
Re:Hellofresh employees' open salary initiative by dragonwriter on Saturday January 15, 2022 @01:16PM (#29948751)
> Depends on your lifestyle but for the bulk of Americans $120k is extremely cushy, at nearly 4x the median salary of $35k

True, though it is closer to 3×

Re:Hellofresh employees' open salary initiative by xref on Saturday January 15, 2022 @01:44PM (#29949024)
lol, ok I'm not quite sure how discussing fractions of an integer would change the conversation in this case since we're already trying to compare one person's $120k to a statistical median of ~$35k.

If you're actually interested in the numbers on different groups they're here [0]. For ex $120k is ~5.77x the median for a woman without a college degree.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Personal_income_in_the_United_...

Re:Hellofresh employees' open salary initiative by dragonwriter on Saturday January 15, 2022 @02:33PM (#29949423)
> I'm not quite sure how discussing fractions of an integer would change the conversation in this case

It doesn't, really, hence the “True” part of “True, though...”

Re:Hellofresh employees' open salary initiative by bradlys on Saturday January 15, 2022 @03:33PM (#29949961)
In Seattle though - it is not a cushy amount. If you’re wanting to buy a home without a huge commute - you need to make more than that.
Re:Hellofresh employees' open salary initiative by xref on Sunday January 16, 2022 @04:17PM (#29960173)
Similarly if you’re looking to buy in the southern tip of Manhattan, Star Island Miami, or Brentwood.
Re:Hellofresh employees' open salary initiative by spenczar5 on Saturday January 15, 2022 @01:46PM (#29949042)
You’re getting unfairly teased for this; I do think its a bit weird. But it’s mostly a problem for FAANG. My advice to everyone who can get a job at FAANG is to put in 5 or 6 years there, raking in a few million dollars (!!). Pay off student debts and secure your future, and then work for ~100k on something you care about or good for the world.

FAANG has to pay so much that they can actually have trouble retaining people. This pattern I have described seems to be becoming more common.

Re:Hellofresh employees' open salary initiative by Invictus0 on Saturday January 15, 2022 @01:14PM (#29948738)
Uh, no, it's plenty for everyone. Leave it to HN to pretend that $120k is a starvation wage.
Re:Hellofresh employees' open salary initiative by erwincoumans on Saturday January 15, 2022 @04:38PM (#29950569)
According to Foster City (Bay area, California) affordable housing, a 4 person family is considered low income at 146,350

See the table under "What are the income limits for the program?"

https://www.fostercity.org/commdev/page/frequently-asked-que...

Re:Hellofresh employees' open salary initiative by smsm42 on Sunday January 16, 2022 @12:12AM (#29953585)
What you're saying is that if you're not motivated by money, and not worried about money, because you already have tons of money, then disclosing how much money you're making and knowing how much money your peers are making won't make much difference. Well, yes, probably. But I don't think this is the common case - especially when we're talking about academia, which attracts people with different set of motivations, usually.
Re:Hellofresh employees' open salary initiative by omginternets on Saturday January 15, 2022 @02:35PM (#29949435)
What do you do at UW? I left academic research in an unrelated discipline (cognitive neuroscience) to become a software engineer. I really enjoy my work, but I also miss the deep expertise and intellectual stimulation of the academe. I might interested in this career path - $120k is plenty.
Re:Hellofresh employees' open salary initiative by spenczar5 on Saturday January 15, 2022 @03:14PM (#29949794)
I write software and basic infrastructure for astronomy. I spend most of my time on the upcoming Rubin Observatory, which is actively hiring software people: https://www.lsst.org/hiring/

Academia has pluses and minuses. Less pay, but the overall mission is more interesting. Really really smart coworkers, but not a lot of structure for growth, since almost everyone just thinks in terms of tenure. Laid back pace, but sometimes too laid back; I wish expectations were a bit higher. Overall I certainly like it more than my time at AWS, but recognize its not for everyone.

Re:Hellofresh employees' open salary initiative by omginternets on Saturday January 15, 2022 @03:28PM (#29949930)
Any advice for making the switch? In particular, which parts of your AWS experience did UWA find most relevant?
Re:Hellofresh employees' open salary initiative by aerosmile on Saturday January 15, 2022 @03:55PM (#29950150)
That's all we needed to know - your primary motivation is not the max salary you can get. On that note, more power to you, I truly believe you're more likely to lead a happy life than most people.

But you're really not in a good position to advocate for open salaries - you're an outlier. Most people deeply, deeply, deeply care about their salaries. It's what gets them out of the bed in the morning, it's what makes their partners respect them, it's what might perhaps provide for private schooling for their kids, etc. Most importantly, it's what makes them feel good about themselves. Yes, those are all wrong reasons, and yes, that's how most people are wired [1].

You'll notice that people who work in academia, military, government jobs, etc all have one thing in common - they are ok with not being able to make more than their peers. They get their happiness from other things in life. But the majority of people out there will happily go the extra mile to get an extra bump in their salary. Open salaries don't allow that - everyone is treated the same, everyone works the same, everyone's output is the same, everyone makes the same salary.

If it sounds familiar to communism, it is - where I was born, everyone's salary was also the same and there was nothing you could do about it. It worked great for people in academia and military (and, coincidentally or not, those are generally the strengths of a communist regime), and it demoralized most people working in other parts of economy where there was supposed to be some competition in the market (which again, coincidentally or not, are the weaknesses of a communist regime). Notably, you won't find a lot of salary transparency in more evolved communist regimes like China, and that perfectly correlated with their economic growth.

[1] Side note: I might sound like I am wired the same way, but I actually took a 6x reduction in salary about 10 years ago and have stayed much below my previous level ever since. Life was incredibly comfortable back then, but I am happier now.

Re:Hellofresh employees' open salary initiative by saulpw on Saturday January 15, 2022 @05:03PM (#29950804)
> Most people deeply, deeply, deeply care about their salaries. It's what gets them out of the bed in the morning...

This seems to be kind of a problem though? Both to be this person, and to have to work with them, and to have society composed of them. Billionaires are a drain on society and the economy, but the core issue is not the wealth inequality itself but the larger attitude in which "most people deeply care about money, first and foremost".

Re:Hellofresh employees' open salary initiative by sokoloff on Saturday January 15, 2022 @09:24PM (#29952673)
When you’re trying to save enough money to have 25x your annual expenses saved by retirement (to support a 4% safe-withdrawal-rate), buy a house in a good school district, and save for their kids’ college, people are naturally concerned about their income. This is single-digit barely-millionaire territory, not billionaire level of income inequality.
Re:Hellofresh employees' open salary initiative by nexuist on Saturday January 15, 2022 @12:15PM (#29948141)
> If the government could just negotiate individual salaries for developers, they could pay them twice as much, fire the contractors, and get the work done for roughly the same quality, and cheaper.

This isn't a bug, it's a feature intended to funnel taxpayer money into private companies. And I know this is usually a statement laced with malice, but it's not really - it makes sense (on paper) that if competent private companies exist the government should contract them instead of scaffolding its own development company inside of the existing bureaucracy.

In practice we know it would probably be cheaper to just hire 10-ish good developers per county for $1m/yr each and get them to do all the digital work for the state. But that's a harder sell that none of the existing private firms (read: campaign donors who stand to gain no money and lose talented employees) would spring for.

Re:Hellofresh employees' open salary initiative by lotsofpulp on Saturday January 15, 2022 @12:12PM (#29948112)
> because the pay can't be negotiated, and it's pegged so far below market it's insulting.

This has nothing to do with transparency. Just because one seller sells something at a certain price does not mean another has to, and same for the buyer.

The pay not being able to be negotiated is a combination of it being a political decision and lack of demand relative to supply.

When the government really wants someone, they start negotiating too.

Edit: one notable example of how it is politically impossible to pay appropriate to get the job done right the first time is the rollout of healthcare.gov and various health insurance websites by state governments. They could have paid enough to attract competent programmers, but the government decided to cheap out. Then it was a political fiasco when the project failed, and they had to open the government wallet to pay for competent programmers. But if they had advertised market pricing for programmers in the first place, and transparently, the the job would have been done right the first time.

Re:Hellofresh employees' open salary initiative by pc86 on Saturday January 15, 2022 @05:10PM (#29950864)
Many (most?) states have a Constitutional prohibition against anyone in the government making more than the Governor. It's literally illegal.

I just looked up the Governor's salary for the state I contracted for, and it's less than a first-year FAANG salary. So in this case, no, they can't really negotiate anything under the current structure.

Re:Hellofresh employees' open salary initiative by mudetroit on Saturday January 15, 2022 @05:42PM (#29951174)
That is incorrect, there isn't a single state in the United States where the highest paid state employee is the governor. They are mostly coaches at state universities, and where they aren't they are upper tier member's of the state university system.

https://worldscholarshipforum.com/wealth/highest-paid-state-...

Re:Hellofresh employees' open salary initiative by sokoloff on Saturday January 15, 2022 @09:17PM (#29952643)
Could you name a couple of these states that have such a Constitutional prohibition (or even a statute) on any state employee making more than the governor?