I will give you that there are some big banks getting into HFT now, and that's a different story, but a statement like "HFT in its worst form amounts to high speed computerized rumor mongering." is wildly inaccurate and shows a complete lack of understanding of the industry.
Furthermore, there is a massive difference between algo trading and HFT. Technically speaking, yes, HFT falls under algo. However, HFT is about speed and making very little profit many times throughout the day, usually by providing liquidity.
Algos on the other hand, especially things like high end models aren't meant for HFT because they take larger amounts of time to run (ie: backtesting). These are used (for example) to determine misprices in the market that will pay off heavily in the long term, or (as others have mentioned below) to buy/sell a large quantity of shares in a way that it won't move the market in the other direction, rather than make an immediate, albeit tiny, profit.
Let me be clear. Anybody that puts an order in not expecting to get executed but to create favorable conditions for their next order is engaging in what I call "high speed rumor mongering". There are lots of variations of this game. Never happens? Always happens? You tell me.
But markets aren't chess. "Rumor-mongering" is a legal term I chose on purpose. It is generally prohibited because it destroys liquidity in markets, which hurts investors and issuers. The term is intentionally objectionable, but not inaccurate. Just don't trouble the regulators to figure it out.
For instance, take a look at the Nanex article What is the Bid/Ask spread of this stock? [1]. Rumor mongering in this case being gaming the weakness of the NBBO.
On a side note, I highly recommend reading through Nanex's Strange Days research section if HFT related market anomalies interests you at all [2].
[1]http://www.nanex.net/Research/bloodbot/bloodbot.html [2]http://www.nanex.net/FlashCrash/FlashCrashAnalysis.html
Could you explain the mechanics of "bluffing orders"?
If by "bluffing", you mean "layering, that is illegal. Also, HFT's are usually the victim of layering, not the perpetrators.
http://www.reuters.com/article/2010/09/13/financial-trillium...
Can you elaborate a bit (even at a high level) about why HFT is particularly bad? I always hear everyone deriding HFT, but never any specific reasons why aside from people complaining about them not contributing anything to society.
Are HFT firms really doing enough volume to even move the needle, or are they simply targeting lower end stocks/securities? I guess I'm still in a forex mindset where billions is not considered an especially large amount.
Algo trading has been around longer than HFT. It was invented to protect the information that that a big order was being executed. This avoided the risk of front running by handing the order to humans or scaring liquidity providers by executing it all at once.
HFT came about when computerized exchanges began to compete with each other for business. Nowadays you go hunting for liquidity. Speed differentials are more important.
I think the OP is likely to agree up until here.
Today HFT in its worst form amounts to high speed computerized rumor mongering. You game the market by bluffing orders and trading faster than your customers. The regulators will never catch on and try to fix it even thought the remedies are many and simple. Moreover our attitudes about who owns information make it very difficult for us to even consider these simple solutions.